Some Boehm Playing

I think you misunderstand me. I was theorizing about the players in the past. When the boehm flute was invented it replaced a lot of the wooden flutes that were going around. A lot of the wooden flutes ended up in pawn shops and were picked up by irish players because they facilitate the music so easily.

My point is that they probably were not that selective about it. A lot of us spend a lot of time here comparing and contrasting very fine details of flutes as far as discussing the weight, rings, etc. This is a result of the internet forum, and the fact that there are just a handful of skilled makers that make wooden flutes. It’s not like comparing yamaha flutes where as long as you know the model number, they’re the same.


I never said, the old players played boehm flutes. Just that they probably didn’t sit around discussing so much about what flute weighed more than another because wooden flutes were so much more common. I also said it was just my theory.

I don’t know anyone who played a boehm other than who I mentioned.

なるほど。いまよくわかりました。 :wink:

I liked it. Alto flute is lovely. I couldn’t find the rest of the site, but I stripped off the music filename from the URL and found some other music files. Very nice.

An alto flutist I like is Ron Korb. Actually, I think his is a bass flute. Not an exclusively Irish musician, but a flutist I enjoy listening to.

Anyway, on the subject, I believe that the boehm flute is not an impediment to playing Irish style flute. The flute is just an instrument. The boehm does have a particular flavor of sound, but the sound can be bent a bit. The main thing is the style, and the style is in the player.

The problem usually is people with classical training sticking their classical knowledge into the Irish music. We have a band in town that claims to be an Irish band but everybody is classically trained. While the flute player is indeed gifted, skilled and capable of playing the music, it simply is not Irish. Same can be said about the fiddler.

If you consider fiddlers for a sec, they play the same exact instrument as violinists. It’s not the violin, it’s the style of playing. Same could be said for the flute.

:wink:

This is quite profound. I had this problem when I “entered irish music.” I had been a classical and jazz pianist for years. I really know music theory. I thought Irish music was easy and that since I could play Chopin’s Nocturnes, “had with the money” was a joke. I had a pretty big ego about it that got me into some arguments.

It took some time, but now I realize how deep ITM is and that while this is chord structure that you could pick apart, what makes it sound irish has nothing to do with classical music at all. Quite humbling.

Yes the flute is but a medium for the player to express him/herself. I like your analogy about the fliddle/violin.

Mike Rafferty played the silver Boehm flute for many years, because it was the best flute he could find at the time. If you want to know what it was like for flute players trying to find decent instruments to play in the years before Hammy Hamilton, Chris Wilkes, Patrick Olwell et al started making wooden flutes for Irish music, read the extensive interview of Mike Rafferty on Brad Hurley’s flute site. (Part two at http://www.firescribble.net/flute/rafferty3.htm talks the most about the flutes mike has played over the years, but really you should read all four parts of this interview. Especially if you’re new to Irish music and lack a context for what you’re trying to play.) I would venture to say that anyone else who has been playing Irish music on the Boehm flute did not set out with that as their goal. Rather, they were finding the best flute they could at the time and playing it. Some switched to wooden flute when the opportunity arose (like Mike Rafferty did), others didn’t and stayed with the wooden flute. Jack Coen is Mike Rafferty’s contemporary in age, musical style and life pattern (both moved from rural Galway to New York City as young men, and have lived and played near there for the rest of their lives) but unlike Mike, Jack has AFAIK almost always played wooden flutes. But they were a series of clunkers and hoseclamp jobs. True story: The first time I ever met Jack Coen was when I was a newbie flute player attending his class at Augusta Irish Week, which happened to be in a science classroom that had a sink. Jack walks in the first morning, takes his old flute out of the case and starts running water through it, while saying “Never, ever do this!” The point was, he had an old flute that he knew he was doing long-term harm to in exchange for short-term playability, but that he would just get rid of in favor of some other old flute whenever it finally conked out. Sort of like folks who drive a series of beat-up old used cars, because that’s all they can find to buy.

Joanie Madden, whose first teacher in the early 1970s was Jack Coen, nevertheless started on the Boehm flute because that was all she could find at the time. So did Mike Rafferty’s daughter Mary, and quite a few other youngsters who started on flute at the time around New York. Over in Ireland, it seems like it may have been easier to find wooden flutes by then, because I don’t know of any Irish players who are contemporaries of Joanie who played or still play the Boehm flute. Although I’m sure there are some of them around. Joanie, as we all know, stayed with the Boehm flute, making that flute fit her music rather than changing her music to fit the flute. Several years ago, though, she did mention to me that she had bought a wooden flute and was playing around with it at home, but of course would never switch to it in performance settings (which for Joanie is probably any time she’s out of the house, given her public’s expectations of her) until she was as comfortable with it as she is with her Boehm flute. I haven’t had the chance to talk with her lately to see if she’s still messing around on the wooden flute or not, but really it doesn’t matter I suppose.

I guess the point of all this is that people starting on flute these days have a much easier time of it when trying to find a good instrument to play. There’s no particular reason to start playing Irish music on a Boehm flute now, since good and not very expensive keyless wooden flutes can be found, with no excessive waitlists either as some seem to think. It’s not impossible to play Irish music the right way on the Boehm flute, but doing so offers a lot of challenges. Why take them on when you don’t need to? Someone switching over from classical flute would have a good reason to think about staying with Boehm flute, but the switch from classical to Irish comes with a whole different set of challenges, which are not unique to the flute. Really, though, I think what the old players did back in their day is still the best thing to do today. Find the best flute you can, and get to playing it. But also give thanks that today the best flute you can find will almost always be a wooden flute.

Caution, maundering follows – it’s hot and I’m avoiding housecleaning.

I remember John Skelton saying that part of the reason the wooden flute became so common in Ireland was because of the mass-produced metal Boehm – when those came out a whole lot of better-off folks in England said (the English equivalent of) “OMG! A flute that doesn’t crack, is fully chromatic, and plays in tune – YEAH!”, and then donated their old wooden instruments to the Salvation Army, churches, community centers, etc. in Ireland or dropped them off in junk shops, which is where all those Rudalls in junk shops, car trunks, etc. came from.

So my understanding is that most folks who could afford a metal Boehm when they first came out basically wanted metal Boehms. Meanwhile, people who couldn’t afford metal Boehms played what they had, which was often wood or Ebonite or some combination of hose clamps and beeswax in an odd band-flute key.

So they worked with what they had; circumstances dictated utilization.

It was only later, like in the 60s or so when us amateur sorts started finding those Rudalls in junk shops and saying “hey! This sounds cool, just like Old McSo-And-So’s recording, only without the hose clamps!”

(Or – economics still at work here – young sorts like John Skelton finding his Hawkes in a London junk shop in the 70s and saying 'hey, plays great and only 30 quid; I can swing that!")

From there, circumstance struck again and folks starting wanting to spend more money to sound more authentic on hand-crafted wooden instruments than on mass-produced metal flutes.

And thus the retro-revolution began.

Now we can visit the pawn shop and pick up a leaky old metal flute for the equivalent of 30 quid; what comes around goes around, I guess!

Anyway, running on with John Kerr said (with apologies), I believe that while we may want to romanticize this whole tradition, it – like many other things, has its economy- and expediency-founded bits! I mean, humans are humans!

But hey, they’re all related, and it’s like John said: “horses for courses.” Play what you’ve got, play it the best you can, if it doesn’t work for you find something that does and play it the best you can, try to figure out why those guys sound like they do (and it ain’t just the flutes), and there you go.

Anent the combo of Irish upbringing + classical training, two words … Sean McGuire.

It’s a discussion that’s been going on for a long, long time and will continue!

There’s my .01.5 …

Or Eugene O’Donnell. And I’m sure many others that folks could mention. But this is not what I meant when I talked of the challenges of going from classical to Irish, because these folks basically learned both classical and Irish music simultaneously, from a young age. (And even if they weren’t actually playing Irish music when they were young classical violinists - as I think Eugene O’Donnell wasn’t, being that he was a champion stepdancer as a youth, not a champion fiddler - they were still surrounded by and hearing the Irish music for years before they might have started to play it.

It’s kind of like the child who grows up in an immigrant household where the parents cling to the old language, but who is speaking English when at school or otherwise outside the house. That kid will naturally grow up fluent in two languages, while an accomplished speaker of one language will find challenges galore in trying to become fluent in another language, especially the older they are when they start trying to learn the other language. Even the best of them may grow quite conversant in the second language, but never to the point where anyone would mistake them for a native speaker.

I’ll talk a little about my situation and why I’m so into the boehm flute right now. I started on a Dixon polymer flute. It has the conical bore and is pretty solid. It has small holes and is not really a loud flute, but held on in a small session. Then I got a Tipple flute. Bigger holes, bigger sound-- a great flute and was so cheap. I recently got out my boehm and played it for a few days and thought, why only play classical music on it? So I started re-learning irish tunes. I didn’t think it was really difficult, just a bit different. I started playing some tunes in odd keys like D minor and G minor and discovered some beautiful music! This went on for a while and I then got out my Irish flutes again. They just seemed so quite and limited compared to the big sound I was getting from my gemeinhardt. So in terms of playing chromatically, (I only had keyless irish flutes) and playing volume, I can’t go back.

The thing is, I haven’t played on a keyed Olwell, Hamilton, McGee, etc. I don’t have that experience, but I just don’t have the money right now. That’s why I can’t say one is better than the other. I really want the keys, though. That’s the factor that’s keeping me on the boehm, and I’m starting to sound not half bad on it.

So Like John mentioned, (for me) it’s the best flute I can play right now. It suits my music needs, and I like a challenge!

I think when I move to Colorado in a few weeks there will be more of an opportunity to play some good keyed wooden flutes then here in Jersey.

Thanks for the article, John. I’m off to read it.

Nice clip, thank you. The Boehm Alto is less often heard, but it’s great instrument.

Lee, stick with my original advice and stay with the Boehm unless you just can’t resist the lure of a keyed wooden flute. IMO the sound you got on the clip is spot on. I started on a Boehm, but had been playing a keyless simple-system flute for Renaissance and Medieval music for many years, so when I picked up ITM, it was natural for me to favor keyless, since that was what everyone used. I’m not sorry I did, but I am so ingrained on simple-system that relearning everything on Boehm is just too much trouble. Besides, I have a really superb eight-key. You, on the other hand, are right where you need to be with your approach, so I see no advantage in changing. If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it, sez I.

Cheers.

Yep, I bought my old leaky, water-damaged Gemeinhardt from craigslist for $45. A couple of pads replaced and it’s perfectly playable. Great sound, fully chromatic and very loud. I can’t play like Lee, but I completely understand where he’s coming from.

I have this small fear. I’ve not yet brought the boehm to a session. (or any flute anywhere as I’m so busy getting ready to pack up everything I own and drive a uhaul to Fort Collins, Colorado)

Do you think people will look down on that kind of thing and give me looks or not want me to play if I’m not using something that resembles an irish flute? I’ve not yet really met people that elitist in the world of ITM, but there were some pretty ignorant things said about using the silver flute in ITM in “the session” forums.

I figure, as long as it sounds good, it’s good, right?

Don’t worry about it. People are always going to find things to get worked up about, and if showing up at a session with a metal flute turns out to be some piece of ammo for them, then phooey. They’ll get over it eventually. There are plenty of people with lovely wooden flutes who can’t play a lick, but hey, we’re all on the same journey and you’re farther down the road than many. Just keep working at it and having fun, and then if the time, desire and funds all come together for a wooden flute, you can start THAT battle! :slight_smile:

Happy moving and safe travels !

Yep. People sometimes tend to abuse what they don’t have or can’t do.

Dear Lee,
Please see my post about Sarah Allen (Flook flute player) and Joannie Madden http://chiffboard.mati.ca/viewtopic.php?p=673521&highlight=alto#673521. Extrapolate.

No, not so fast Buster! :smiling_imp:
Not only must you sound good but you must be CONFIDENT that you sound good. Hecklers, like dogs, have a way of picking up on fear, even if you are not doing anything bad.

Best Wishes.
:slight_smile:

I don’t care what kind of flute you bring to a session.

If you can play the music, I don’t care if you play it on a water hose.

If you can’t play the music, then having a top-end Olwell isn’t going to help matters any.

I’ve played wooden flute alongside silver flute with not a difficulty on either side.

–James

Thanks. Still working on the bansuri as well… But I won’t be posting and videos of that anytime soon :blush:

Lee, come to our session and bring your Gemeinhardt. We had a tap dancer tonight and people were fine with that. They are fine with me noodling away at a respectable distance. So far I have seen none of the snobbishness you read about on Internet forums.

You’re obviously quite a newbie. Session snobbishness can be very very subtle and you need to be a veteran to detect it and produce it.

Patent snobbishness is usually the work of underdeveloped types who don’t know anything about the tradition of snobbery.