Caution, maundering follows – it’s hot and I’m avoiding housecleaning.
I remember John Skelton saying that part of the reason the wooden flute became so common in Ireland was because of the mass-produced metal Boehm – when those came out a whole lot of better-off folks in England said (the English equivalent of) “OMG! A flute that doesn’t crack, is fully chromatic, and plays in tune – YEAH!”, and then donated their old wooden instruments to the Salvation Army, churches, community centers, etc. in Ireland or dropped them off in junk shops, which is where all those Rudalls in junk shops, car trunks, etc. came from.
So my understanding is that most folks who could afford a metal Boehm when they first came out basically wanted metal Boehms. Meanwhile, people who couldn’t afford metal Boehms played what they had, which was often wood or Ebonite or some combination of hose clamps and beeswax in an odd band-flute key.
So they worked with what they had; circumstances dictated utilization.
It was only later, like in the 60s or so when us amateur sorts started finding those Rudalls in junk shops and saying “hey! This sounds cool, just like Old McSo-And-So’s recording, only without the hose clamps!”
(Or – economics still at work here – young sorts like John Skelton finding his Hawkes in a London junk shop in the 70s and saying 'hey, plays great and only 30 quid; I can swing that!")
From there, circumstance struck again and folks starting wanting to spend more money to sound more authentic on hand-crafted wooden instruments than on mass-produced metal flutes.
And thus the retro-revolution began.
Now we can visit the pawn shop and pick up a leaky old metal flute for the equivalent of 30 quid; what comes around goes around, I guess!
Anyway, running on with John Kerr said (with apologies), I believe that while we may want to romanticize this whole tradition, it – like many other things, has its economy- and expediency-founded bits! I mean, humans are humans!
But hey, they’re all related, and it’s like John said: “horses for courses.” Play what you’ve got, play it the best you can, if it doesn’t work for you find something that does and play it the best you can, try to figure out why those guys sound like they do (and it ain’t just the flutes), and there you go.
Anent the combo of Irish upbringing + classical training, two words … Sean McGuire.
It’s a discussion that’s been going on for a long, long time and will continue!
There’s my .01.5 …