Does anyone who owns a Silkstone low D care to give us a little review of it?
I think Paul Hayward is probably the most underrated whistle maker on Earth.
I have several Silkstone’s and I love them all, but I find it odd that his low D is rarely mentioned here.
In fact, Feadan is the only person I know of who has ever mentioned owning one.
I’ve been considering buying one for quite some time, but I’ve been waiting to see someone praising theirs before I take the plunge.
“[Rain Dogs] …the ones you see wanderin’ around after a rain. Ones that can’t find their way back home. See the rain washes off the scent off all the mail boxes and the lamposts, fire hydrants…”
Tom Waits
[ This Message was edited by: raindog1970 on 2001-11-13 20:49 ]
I think Paul Hayward is probably the most underrated whistle maker on Earth.
–snip–
In fact, Feadan is the only person I know of who has ever mentioned owning one.
I’ve been considering buying one for quite some time, but I’ve been waiting to see someone praising theirs before I take the plunge.
Despite my issues with the high B on the Silkstone alloy D I have to wholeheartedly agree that Paul Hayward makes truly awesome whistles. So here are my thoughts on the low D. Let me first qualify my statements by mentioning that I also own Low D whistles by Copeland, Overton, Dixon, & Howard (the crappy older model). Were I forced to give up all my Low D whistles but one, I would without hesitation choose the Silkstone. Although it is not as loud as the Copeland the Silkstone makes up for it by being the most playable. The change in breath pressure across the octaves is way smooth and the volume and tone balance is near perfection. And, as usual with Paul’s whistles, the intonation is to die for. The two finger C natural is brilliant. The second octave four finger (oxx xxo) C natural is a tad sharp but not bad at all. Piper fingering is the best for this whistle but those with long fingers could conceivably use normal whistle fingering (not quite as easily as the Dixon). If it ain’t obvious by now I would highly recommend the Silkstone Low D to any and everyone.
Cheers,
David
P.S. The high B issue is not a problem with the Low D at all.
I played one several times
at The Whistle Shop.
I thought it quite good, definitely
worth the money, but not in the
class of the Copeland low D–good
enough, but not especially good.
However I might have revised my opinion
if I had played it more.
While the alloy high d is extremely impressive and deserving of high praise, I find the Low D to be unimpressive. I don’t find anything special about it. My mouth dropped when I read that someone thought it was in the same class with some of the ones mentioned. I disagree.
I own a Silkstone Low D and it is definately a very good whistle. Well made and rather unique(the windway is an acetal fipple plug and a PVC mouthpiece top), it is comfortable to play and also quite loud. The finger holes are the most comfortable and carefully sanded I have ever seen. I find that it is agreeable to most alternate fingerings and has a unique sound; almost like a plastic whistle, but not quite, and much nicer. I own a Copeland, a Cillian O’Briain, and an Overton Low D and the Silkstone still gets play-time. Although not comparable to the Copeland it is a fine instrument by a fine craftsman. The one drawback… it’s not as pretty as the Copland! I’m not crazy about the copper tuning sleeve and collar at the bottom of the bore, but who cares what it looks like when it plays as well as it does. The alloy Soprano D is a treat, too.
JessieK wrote:
…I don’t find anything special about it. My mouth dropped when I read that someone thought it was in the same class with some of the ones mentioned. I disagree.
and jim stone wrote:
I thought it quite good, definitely worth the money, but not in the class of the Copeland low D–good enough, but not especially good.
It think it would be more helpful to those considering a purchase if you two could give a little more information as to why you feel the way you do about the Silkstone Low D.
Cheers,
David
[ This Message was edited by: Feadan on 2001-11-16 12:09 ]
Ok, David. I said I found nothing special about it. I mean, it’s a run of the mill, no problems, user-friendly whistle, but I think the tone is cloudy and uninteresting, not at all in the same league as his high alloy c and d whistles. It plays similarly to a Burke aluminum Low D, which I think plays similarly to an Overton, Chieftain, or Kerry Pro. I think the Silkstone alloy Low D and the Burke aluminum Low D play more easily (not as much pressure or volume) than the others I mentioned, but there is nothing in the tone that sings. A good Copeland Low D can sound reedy and rich. I don’t think a Silkstone Low D can do that. However, I do think Paul Hayward’s alloy high c and d whistles are amazing, and among the best.
Jessie
[ This Message was edited by: JessieK on 2001-11-16 12:31 ]
Right. I thought the Silkstone low D handles
well and looks very good, but the tone
struck me as unremarkable–not bad, but
not especially good. Again I played it
only for a few minutes. It’s
hard for me to assess a whistle
without getting to know it, especially
one by a very good whistle maker. I bought
a Silkstone alloy C which is a better
whistle, I think, with a more interesting
sound, though I’m still getting used to it.
These are beautifully designed whistles,
but the same designs and materials
can have pretty different tonal properties
in different keys.