I’ve got a polymer low D which I got pretty recently. I like it a lot, though I’m NOT primarily a whistle player (flute, though I’m increasingly interested in whistles). it’s nicely made - no sharpness in the holes; pretty sound - breathy, mellow, woody; tuning is absolutely spot on. I find it easy to play. I would swap up, but only for something significantly more expensive. For the money I think it’s absolutely fab and I found the maker really friendly and helpful, too. It is on the quiet side, but for playing purely for my own pleasure I find it great.
I’m late to this party…but I’ve never heard of or seen a Shearwater…which only stands to reason if they’re newish whistles.
Seems to be a lot of brand-spanking-new posters praising this whistle that hardly anyone has ever heard of …and they found their way here as soon as the new whistle was mentioned. I can smell the stockyard from my front porch…
[ Image removed. - Mod. ]
However, I’m more apt to give consideration to a long time poster of this board over the singletons, so if you pick one up, I’m sure we’d all be interested in hearing your opinion. On their website, the whistle sound files actually didn’t sound too bad. But the way this thread unfolded, it really does feel like folks were trying to play us for dupes.
Locked temporarily for review and comment. - Mod.
Reviewed and researched. And I find no reason or prima facie evidence to question the integrity of any of the postings to this thread, new users or old, either before or after its revival. Registering in order to comment on one’s whistle is far from unusual - especially if the maker may refer new players to this board as a resource. A small maker, not much history or information. Comments both good and bad from a few with hands-on experience. It all seems pretty normal, and people can make up their own minds.
Reopened. - Mod.
Thank you!
I had no point to prove at all, and no desire to mislead anyone, I just wanted to offer my experience. I’d happily post pictures/sound files (if I can work out how to do the sound files, and if anyone will excuse my beginnernoise) if anyone were interested.
I wanted to come back to this with a little more perspective. I have recently bought a second-hand Howard low D, which has made me rethink a little.
First, I’d like to revise my statement that the Shearwater is quiet. I haven’t tried playing either outdoors, but in the biggest room in my house, it isn’t noticeably quieter than the Howard. I think perhaps my expectations of volume were a little over-ambitious!
Compared to the Howard it uses more breath [I don’t mind this at all as I come from the flute], but there is no danger at all of it jumping into the second octave when playing hard into the low notes unless it’s intentional.
It’s incredibly easy to play, due not least to the offset D (whistle is pretty much exactly the same diameter as the Howard but easier by a factor of about a million), doesn’t clog or require warming up, and I can play it pretty much indefinitely without my thumbs hurting despite my dislike of proper pipers grip.
It makes a very nice noise indeed. Very different to the Howard (sorry to keep going on about that but it’s my current comparison) but very pretty.
I can find three Ds on it no hassles; I need to find the fingering for the notes above the third D to see if I can get them too.
at forty quid including postage it’s an absolute steal and I really can’t be nice enough about it. I’m seriously considering an alloy one.
JTC -
I’m presuming the comments were aimed at me!
Yes I’m a new poster, and I only posted that because I happened to see it and that not many people had commented. I signed up to buy an Overton whistle I saw listed. I realise how that might have looked, and I did vanish straight after posting that, however, I just wanted to offer my experience of that instrument as it seemed not many people had heard of it and I’d just bought one, no ulterior motive. I read this forum a bit, but as I’m inexperienced I don’t comment a lot.
Kat