Restoring Cork Placement by Sound

-Too thorough oiling allowed my cork to slip north recently when swabbing the headjoint afterward, making high octave impossible and low octave tone poor. I have the maker’s position specs, but, too lazy for a Home Depot trip for a millimeter rule, placed it by sound. I got the golden microspot after the labors of Hercules- where low octave is strong and high octave accessible and sweet, and a fine"nyaahh" heard throughout. Cleaning the Augean stables was sheer hell, however. :wink:

-It dawned on this slow boat later this may be the best way to place a cork as individual’s lipping/play style is integrated into placement rather than relying on static measurement. I will measure this position to find it easily again, but feel a little pride (a deadly sin) having found it without a tool.

-How can it be wrong when it sounds so right? I don’t know if variance between players should affect optimum cork position but like this where currently set.

By measure do you mean buying that millimeter tool, or sticking a dowel down the head joint and marking the dowel with a pen? (I have a cleaning rod with the marks on one end that silver flute players center in the embouchure to set the “cork”)

-I’ve been using the blunt end of a clean chopstick for moving the cork unless it has to go south in which case a finger inserted
through the cap’s bore can push it down. I will mark the embouchure center point on the chopstick and eventually use a millimeter rule to see how the favored position conforms to the maker’s spec. -Perhaps a dowel would be better as the chopstick could dent the cork face when pressure is applied.

I’ve recently come to a revelation regarding cork position!

:astonished:

I have taken out the digital tuner and spent at least 20 min. each, setting the cork on 5 different flutes.

A few weeks ago I set to oil the bore on one of the flutes. So I marked the center of the embouchure on the cleaning rod, prior to pulling the cork and fully oiling inside the head (unlined). Over time swabbing out the other 4 flutes, I checked the mark on the rod and LOW AND BEHOLD ALL OF THE CORKS HAD BEEN SET WITHIN + or - a millimeter or two.

Therefore I would say that the cork position is unique to the player.

My cork depth is greater than the 19 mm typical of most original flutes.

Another interesting note is that the head inside diameters of my flutes vary by approximately 2 mm. Yet the cork position is almost identical.

I was inspired by this post to play around with the position of my stopper, since I’ve marked my cleaning rod appropriately. It’s now significantly closer to the end, the tone is WAY warmer (although there was definitely a point beyond which the tone got thinner and muddier), and the intonation is still good. Wow, does it sound great now!! Thanks!

Which notes do you all check?

I would think that depending on the octaves that you most commonly use would affect the place that you would want your cork (for example if you need the low D but rarely anything in the third octave, you would bee tuning it much differently than some one else might).

(just asking because I am still trying to get myself in tune, not the instrument)

James Galway states that he mostly pushes the cork further out (towards the crown) by a millimeter or two on his flutes, which are of course metal. I think the position of about the same as the headjoint diameter is merely a guide not an absolute and each flute will be slightly different. On my wood flute I drop an american dime into the head and it becomes a base for pushing the cork with a cleaning rod without damaging it. Remove the dime for playing of course.

I use a dime, too, to protect the cork.

I also agree that cork position is individual, but my Seery and my Sweet are set at different positions by about 3mm.

I also find it easier not to mark the half way point of the embouchure hole on a dowell but rather to mark the crown end on a dowell - much less guessing than what’s half way on the embouchure!

Eric

-Measuring from the top end seems a good idea to me too.
Brian

If the mark is still in the embouchure hole, you’re fine. However, if you’re marking the distance from the crown (end cap) to the cork, that measurement will vary if you replace your cork with one of a different length.

Kevin Krell