reach on a low D

I just played a friends Shaw low D and was surprised that my hand actually fit. I’ve been playing a Susato G (trying to work my way down) and it seemed that the Shaw had a smaller reach than the Susato. Is there a whistle that is spaced like a Shaw but maybe a bit shorter?

Well the smaller reach on the Shaw is due to the fact that it’s a conical bore, so simply by design, you’re allowed smaller holes, and a smaller stretch, maybe not by a whole lot, but smaller still. Where as the Susato, is a cylindrical bore, so the holes are usually spaced out a little more and/or are bigger, usually depends on the maker. I don’t know of any whistle with the parameters you’re looking for, perhaps other whistlers could chime in on that note.

Design is the key. Sometimes it is the conical bore, sometimes it is the selection of hole sizing and placement and/or bore diameter.

My Bleazey is conical, but only slightly so and my wife had no trouble at all with the reach.

The Jubillee PVC I had was obviously cylindrical and it had a very easy reach as well, maybe even better than the Bleazey for some holes.

Some aspects of performance character are compromised for each change: smaller holes usually reduces volume, certain hole placements make the whistle more tempermental etc.

The shortest-reach low D that’s out there, probably, is the Susato fitted with keys.
The basic problem with low D’s is that if every hole was in its “acoustically correct position” (as Boehm put it) every note would be equally full and strong but the finger stretch would be hard to manage. This is especially true for the lowest hole, from which E sounds. The E hole should ideally be the same size as the F# hole and located halfway between the F# hole and the bottom of the whistle. That would give you a low E that’s as strong as the bottom D and F#. But, few would want to play such a whistle. So, that hole on low D’s is placed rather too high on the bore, and the hole must therefore be reduced in size, these combining to make the low E weaker than the surrounding F# and bottom D.
Burke makes two models of low D, the “pro” which has the bottom hole rather far down for a strong E, and the “EZ” with the bottom hole further up which is more comfortable but results of course in a weaker low E.
As said above, the narrowing of the lower part of the bore on a conical flute or whistle has a flattening effect on the lower notes making for an easier finger stretch, but often also for a weaker tone.
Actually I think there’s a site somewhere with a low D whistle fingerhole placement comparison chart.
One of the things I love about the Burke “pro” is the evenness of the tone across the range, which is probably a result of the rather evenly spaced and sized tone holes.

Hi Everyone,
I don’t normally post, just lurk, but Panceltic Piper’s explanation was impressive and very accurate. It reminds me of a question that seemed to haunt Einstein: He asked, “I wonder if God had a choice on how he made the universe?”. Obviously, there are almost unlimited numbers of combinations that will produce an instrument that is somewhat in tune and has some of the best characteristics we wish for in a low whistle, but after many hours and a rather large heap of discarded prototypes, it is clear that Theobold Boehm was correct. However, we must make the instruments so that people can play them, and therein the compromises begin and performance is lost. Many characteristics that make a good low whistle are not even noticed by the average player, but will only be noticed by the very best players, like transient response and dynamic power and balance across the entire range of the instrument, and also accessibility to each and every note. Poking 6 holes in a tube and fitting a fipple will get you a low whistle, but not necessarily a good one. I have compared my layouts with other excellent makers and the tonehole layouts are very similar. If a low D is too easy to reach, it probably is not a very good one. Conical bores do allow smaller and closer spacing between the bottom toneholes, but the problem is that they are invariably sharp in the second octave. If intonation is not important, then they are a good choice, though, because they are easier to cover. Again, we have to compromise good octave tuning to gain that advantage. The real issue, is not the size of the instrument for 90% of adults who wish to learn to play a low whistle, but whether they are willing to learn good technique and willing to practice until that technique feels natural. If so, any really good low whistle will be your best choice and then you can get a well balanced, powerful and in tune instrument to play instead of an inferior compromised one. My EZ is exactly identical to my Viper, except for the bottom tonehole, and therefore has only one small fault, the slightly weaker E note. It still does retain all the other good characteristics of an optimally designed low D, because all the other toneholes are in a position that is optimal or close to it. Most people will not be able to tell the difference when playing tunes, but it just cannot be quite as good as the Viper, which has the bottom tonehole in a position that is closer to the “correct” one, but still in the range that allows normal human hands using the piper fingering to play.
I have seen 12 year old girls with medium sized fingers play the Viper easily and full grown men with rather large hands struggle with it. In most cases, with adults with medium to large hands, it is all about skill, and technique and committment to practice and to gain skill with the instrument, not about arbitrarily moving toneholes around like furniture and seeing if that feels right or does not offend one’s feng shui.
Hope this helps a bit.
All the best
Mike

My already high estimation of the skill of whistlemaking is higher now knowing you struggle with these dynamics. Einstiens question has been answered in my estimation, yes, God had design limits suited to the fragility and the uniqueness of His creatures.

Honored to hear from you on this site.

Don in AZ

My already high estimation of the skill of whistlemaking is higher now knowing you struggle with these dynamics. Einstiens question has been answered in my estimation, yes, God had design limits suited to the fragility and the uniqueness of His creatures.

Honored to hear from you on this site.

Don in AZ

Thanks for the great information. Now, I was wondering if anyone has a Burke EZ they want to sell :smiley:.

Just so you know, Overton makes a short reach low D. My favorite low D is my MK. I find it has the best intonation of any low D I have played and the balance between notes is first rate. It does not suffer from a weak E note and the reach is not a problem. My wife has small hands and has no problem playing the MK; however, the reach is too much for her on my standard Overton. Good luck, Cyril.

Actually, I think the question is:

Could god make a low D whistle with a finger spacing that he couldn’t reach?

:smiley:


Great thread everyone.

Well, it looks like I found a used Shaw low D. A Burke or Overton would be great, but alas, both are out of my price range. I did find a used Shaw G to replace the Susato today at a local music store. So now for another question…

Who is a good tweaker for Shaws. I know Jerry Freeman does, but I read somewhere that he only does certain keys. The one my friend has had the fipple tweaked and also had the last tone hole raised.

The reach might have been good on that Shaw low D but didn’t it take alot of Air to play? It seems there’s always a trade off. Love to try one of those MK’s. Just not in the buget right now!

I recently got a Howard low D from Doc. The holes are big and harder to reach than an Overton but it sure is easy to blow (except the top two notes especially the b which is also out of tune) Anyways, its always a trade off of one thing or another.

It’s always good to hear from M.B.! I have a low E of his that I really like…Thanks!

Nate

The low D I tried last night was teaked and the air wasn’t too bad at all. I was surprised. The G I picked up today took more air. That’s why I need a tweaker now.

Thank Michael for the kind words and most importantly all the research and work you put into the design of the Pro Viper, which is the best low D I’ve played. From the day I got it, I just couldn’t put it down.
There were three things I had issues with initially, which however I fully realised were absolutely necessary, which were 1) the amount of wind it requires 2) the wide finger spacing on the upper hand and 3) the very large diameter tubing which made it a bit of a log to hold. All it has taken to get used to these things is playing, playing, and more playing.
The more I play it, the more I appreciate how good it is. The extremely even voicing and power combined with perfect intonation make it a joy. Now I’ve had a chance to compare it with an MK, an Overton (admittedly an old one), a Copeland (admittedly a new one), and a Susato and I’m sticking with the Burke.
Now if only I had the money to get a low C, a low E flat, a low E, and a low F…
About the original topic of finger spacing, you should be able to comfortably play any low D if you use the piper’s grip and practice, practice, practice.

Gee Whiz!

Yeah, I have a Burke Low F and I must say, even though I have a Copeland Low D, I intend on getting a Pro Viper Low D sometime soon.

Sure…email me at tyghress@aol.com

Tyghress, e-mail sent.