Questions about the Ennis Book

Hi Everyone,

I have some questions about Pat Mitchell’s Ennis book and I’d like to ask the more experienced pipers if they could help me understand the transcriptions better.

For “The Butcher’s March” (pg 69)

  1. What does it mean to grace the G roll on bars 4, 8, and 12 with a g?

For “When the Cock Crows it is Day” (pg 71)

  1. How do you execute the bunch of grace notes (Bb Bnat sliding up to accented Cnat) in the first note of bar 26?

For “The Smokey House” (pg 325)

  1. In bar 1, what does it mean to grace a Cnat with an A?

  2. In bar 3, what does it mean to grace a Cnat with a G?

As much as I think the Ennis book is great for its detail, I need quite a bit effort deciphering what the transcriptions mean. If there are any other people who have questions about the transcriptions too, maybe it’ll be good to post them together with this thread.

“Edited 100 times in total”
Holey Moley ,your signature should read,
I used to be indecisive,but now I’m not so sure.;


RORY

I’ll just answer the first question.

The cut before the G roll is similar to what Pat Mitchell described in the Willie Clancy book as the double cut roll. Ennis uses it here as he’s coming to the G roll from A which would normally be the cut note on the G roll. So he plays the G then the G roll - grace G, cut A to start the short roll. The first time on the recording it comes over very clearly. He also rolls this note off the knee.

You need to listen to some of the recordings to get to grips with what’s going on in the playing and what’s being written down.

Hope this helps

Ken

Ah okay I get what it means now. The G appears just for the slightest bit such that an A grace note can be executed for the short G roll that follows an A. I did listen to the recordings and all I heard was a short G roll - didn’t think of the mechanics required to execute the G roll in that context.

Thanks for coming to the rescue Ken.

I went back to take a listen and realised that the bunch of grace notes to the accented Cnat denotes bending the Cnat with the left index finger, chanter off the knee. But is there any special way of fingering such that the bending starts from as low as Bb?

David Power showed us how to take it from G to Cnat. Start lifting the top two fingers of the lower hand, like you are playing a G…at the same time, begin cracking the index finger of the upper hand to start the Cnat.

-g