Here is a series of relatively short audio interviews with leading
philosophers on ‘bite-sized topics,’ e.g. the relation of mind to
body, the nature of morality, and so on. Gives one a good
idea of what these folks sound like.
Here’s something extraordinarily good,
Mary Warnock on Sartre’s Existentialism.
This is what British women philosophers of
an older generation often sound like.
For those willing to try something outside the realm of moral
philosophy, the David Papineau audio on physicalism (is the
mind entirely physical?) is very good. These interviews are excellent,
the interviewers are themselves philosophers, they’re going
as deep as they can without getting technical.
You’all are going to do the ‘gaiety and frivolity’ routine.
But I know all about the people interviewed on
Philosopy Bites. I know all the sexual scandals.
I have photos, even videos, of famous philosophers
nude with animals. How do you think I get published;
indeed, how do you think I got a job?
A thorough search of the archives shows no
compromising anything about Weeks, for crying
out loud. But Mary Warnock! Hubba hubba!
What a load of crap. I could only listen to his mealy-mouthed prattle for about half-way through before I had to turn it off. As soon as he got to asserting that “hope” can only be a religious virtue, without substantiating this assertion, I knew he was was lost in a woods of his own confusion.
Cottingham has an agenda that isn’t entirely explicit.
Goes by the name of Roman Catholicism. I’ve been
arguing with him for years. Also he isn’t sure that God
exists, but he thinks that religious practice is a way
to find out, that it leads to faith. Again, I’ve
been arguing with him for years.
I don’t think he says that
hope can only be a religious virtue; rather he appeals
to religious virtues like faith, hope, and love as a spiritual
response to our confrontation with the fragility and absurdity
of human life. He does think that spirituality is
a necessary dimension to a meaningful human life,
at least to one that confronts life’s realities.
Note that the interviewers are asking all the right
questions. By the way, the point of listening to these audios isn’t
to agree with these people or even to like them.
Okay, I have to admit I like Mary Warnock. I don’t particularly agree with her on many points, but she seems a very pleasant (though dangerous) person.
Very tough minded, yes? And doesn’t pull her punches.
(I liked the interviewers getting into sartre’s taking speed.)
Yes, I think she is dangerous–her other audio concerning
how philosophy has helped her in public life
is scary.
By the way, I offered these two audios because they
are accessible. Most of us wonder about the meaning
of life and we’ve all heard of Sartre and existentialism.
But some of these other audios are terrifically good,
e.g. Papineau on whether mental events are entirely
physical. More
scientific in nature, however. These people are saying what
they really think, about as intelligently and deeply
as the format will allow.
Anybody who
wants to know what recent philosophy is like,
it’s here.
As soon as I heard her describe, but not opinionate on, Sartre, I knew she was making a concerted effort to be in complete control of her words without seeming to, and realized that words are her weapons, and she wields them with great skill. If you don’t express yourself clearly and concisely, she will hand you your balls on a tray. I don’t think I could have a conversation with someone like that, but it is quite the entertainment in itself just to listen to her.
Geoffrey Warnock, her husband, also a philosopher:
“To be clear-headed rather than confused; lucid rather than obscure; rational rather than otherwise; and to be neither more, nor less, sure of things than is justifiable by argument or evidence. That is worth trying for.”