( Some comments are added to the end from Phil that were sent to me today.)
I have had some time to play the low D Bleazey ( http://www.bleazey.co.uk/ )now, not as much as I would have liked or should have. I am being REALLY careful with this gem. Bleazey recommends only 15 minutes a day to get started and working up over a few weeks, so I am taking it REALLY slow. The fact that my wife can actually PLAY this whistle takes away from MY playing time as well. More on that later.
Last night we were playing some tunes. Towards the end of our time I was bouncing back and forth between the Overton and the Bleazey. I asked Renee to turn around and listen to me play. This is the result…
She was able to tell me when I was playing each instrument. She told me that the Overton and the Bleazey played very much in tune and sounded very nice to her. Now here is the difference…
She told me the biggest difference is that the Bleazey SINGS. I think that is a good thing. She also said it has a sort of growly sort of sound. (Note To Self: Gotta get the recording thing resolved!!!)
Some other observations:
The B takes a bit more air and has a bit less back pressure than the O. Not a whole lot, but enough to make you take notice. I would say it is fairly similar to the Alba I recently had, but without a direct comparison I cannot say for sure. I do have low D’s that take more air and have less back pressure than the B.
What else… It is wood (Mopane) and visually very pleasing to the eye. The holes are a bit on the small side and that make half holing a bit difficult. Where I can half hole a second octive D# on the O it is nearly impossible at this point on the B. I was able to manage a decent G# last night. ( I have also discovered that XXO XXO works like a charm!!! )
It is heavy. The walls of this whistle are quite thick. It is cylindrical or very, very slightly conical. I will have to ask Phil about that. ( see notes at the end of this )
IT DOES NOT CLOG! Period. The fipple plug is aromatic cedar and although I have seen moisture buld up on both the low and high whistle, this has always been on the blade ramp and never in the windway.
This whistle makes my wife happy when I play it. Well, so does the Overton and most of the rest of my low whistles. I think this is a different kind of happy, more like “That is a REALLY nice sound” happy. Definately not a “I am soooo happy he is playing that EXPENSIVE piece of wood” happy.
The result of all this is the Bleazey, so far, appears to be a fine, easy to play instrument. It has a bit of an edge over the Overton in sound quality. Visually there is no question the Bleazey is the winner. The Overton, at least at this time, will NOT be going away though.
Please let me know if there is any other area you would like me to address. I would have a difficult time measuring responsiveness or speed as I am still a slow player and just now starting to experiment with ornamentation.
Now Phil’s comments:
Both whistles are very definately conical bore difference from top to bottom in the High D is 1.5 mm and on the Low D almost 10 mm.
… During an extended playing session the block expands and rises up in the windway (on the larger instruments it is not just a cylindrical block but has a projection which stands up in the windway to allow this movement to take place) this means that when it comes to its optimum moisture content it will use a little less air than it does at the moment while you are still playing it in. During the voicing process I artificially raise the moisture content of the windway floor to simulate extended playing . Achieving that “non-clogging” attribute is one of the largest contributors to the high cost of these instruments.
Hope this helps.
Regards
Phil