I’ve played keyboard and clarinet most of my life, and just got into whistling. I love the instrument, along with the variety of music you can play with it.
I began learning with a Clarke Sweetone Soprano D and a Generation Eb (for hymns); my next goal is to get started on a Low D. From what I’ve heard the ethereal, breathy tone of Davey Spillane in Riverdance is an Overton. This is the tone I am shooting for. It seems the Celtic Christian group"Eden’s Bridge" also plays this same whistle, as they sound identical. Could someone please confirm this?
Also, much of the hymnody that I am playing at church is written in Eb. What I’ve found is the High Eb whistles are too high, so I want to get a High Bb (Bb below middle C) and use this to play in the key of Eb. Could someone recommend a good Bb whistle that is not too much money - I’m trying to save my budget for a good Low D.
Try Generation, a cheapie, but the Bb is one of its kind. Otherwise Impempe (South Africa) is a good choice, only $40,-, I have an Impempe Bb. It’s beautifully made with a very lovely complex sound.
arnie, have you tried Impempe low D whistle? I didn’t know Impempe whistles until now, I visited the webpage and they look awesome, and aren’t too expensive..
So… Generation has a good B flat? I am also wondering what to get since the one I have is a no-name and it’s not all that great. Already am getting cracks in the plastic mouthpiece.
As I recall, it was an Overton on Riverdance. Also, I remember there is some controversy as to what it was.
If you want a really good Bb, Reyburn makes them in both equal and just temperment. I would go with “just” if you are accompanying vocalists and or piano. Best, Cyril.
I’m wondering if your no-name is a Generation Bb with the decal worn off or missing. I’m not aware of any inexpensive mass produced Bb whistles other than Generation. What color is the mouthpiece? Is it a brass tube or nickle-plated tube? I also think Generation makes a great Bb whistle, but maybe you got a flawed one (if that is what you have).
I bought it new, and the paper packaging just said “Tin Whistle”. I dont remember what key it is in. It looks to me nickel, but it might be aluminum, I dunno. The mouthpiece is black plastic. The holes are not perfectly round, looks like they didnt to a to good of a job when making the holes.
Interesting. Just intonation with pure fifths etc. does make sense for vocals. As far as I know, ET equal temperament has been a piano tuning standard since the early 19th century, and the practical norm since the early 20th. Before that, it was various mean temperaments. But I know just and mean temperaments are sometimes applied to keyboards for playing earlier pre-Romantic repertoire, or for modern experimental pieces. Maybe yours is one of those.
I think my piano is in I-8 temperament. This is the special tuning that results from it bouncing around in a trailer on Interstate 8 between Phoenix and San Diego and never being retuned.
Yikes! It sounds like you deserve a real whistle to match your interest. The one you have sounds like it’s a toy piece of you know what. For ~$10 US you can get yourself a nice Generation-style D whistle that can last you literally a lifetime. So go for it, then stick around Chiff & Fipple as you progress. Welcome aboard …
Yea, I figured it wasn’t much good, but I had heard that cheap tin whistles dont really mean crap.. in this case it prolly does heh. Thats kinda why I joined here, to see if either something can be done, or what should I try to go and get.
I can get a Feadog, or a Penny Whistle, but I dont know which one I should go wit. (they are both about the same price, and I want to try out a better whistle before spending too much, though the shipping prices for ebay really sucks).
I have Impempe D, Bb, C and F, all awesome. I like my Impempe even better than my Sindt, but that’s personal. I don’t know how the low D is. If I didn’t have a low D already, I would really consider it. Impempe is known to be soft, well my Sindt and Gens are much softer. Impempe is worth its price 3 times!! And Ian Turnbull is a very nice guy to deal with: he sent me a Bb only to try and swapped the F for me which had a mistake, and he has no waiting list.
Genereation is as a cheapie almost known for its well-sounding Bb. I put in a little putty and cleaned the inside of the plastic to make it smooth and now I’m also able to tune it. It has an awesome sound with a very strong bell-note.