Newbie whistler looking for first Low D and good Bb

Hi,

I’ve played keyboard and clarinet most of my life, and just got into whistling. I love the instrument, along with the variety of music you can play with it.

I began learning with a Clarke Sweetone Soprano D and a Generation Eb (for hymns); my next goal is to get started on a Low D. From what I’ve heard the ethereal, breathy tone of Davey Spillane in Riverdance is an Overton. This is the tone I am shooting for. It seems the Celtic Christian group"Eden’s Bridge" also plays this same whistle, as they sound identical. Could someone please confirm this?

Also, much of the hymnody that I am playing at church is written in Eb. What I’ve found is the High Eb whistles are too high, so I want to get a High Bb (Bb below middle C) and use this to play in the key of Eb. Could someone recommend a good Bb whistle that is not too much money - I’m trying to save my budget for a good Low D.

Thanks. :slight_smile:

Try Generation, a cheapie, but the Bb is one of its kind. Otherwise Impempe (South Africa) is a good choice, only $40,-, I have an Impempe Bb. It’s beautifully made with a very lovely complex sound.

arnie, have you tried Impempe low D whistle? I didn’t know Impempe whistles until now, I visited the webpage and they look awesome, and aren’t too expensive..

A Gen Bb is a good place to start.

Also, I sent you a private message.

So… Generation has a good B flat? I am also wondering what to get since the one I have is a no-name and it’s not all that great. Already am getting cracks in the plastic mouthpiece.

As I recall, it was an Overton on Riverdance. Also, I remember there is some controversy as to what it was.

If you want a really good Bb, Reyburn makes them in both equal and just temperment. I would go with “just” if you are accompanying vocalists and or piano. Best, Cyril.

Shouldn’t equal temperament work better with piano, which is also usually equal tempered nowadays? Just thinking out loud.

I’m wondering if your no-name is a Generation Bb with the decal worn off or missing. I’m not aware of any inexpensive mass produced Bb whistles other than Generation. What color is the mouthpiece? Is it a brass tube or nickle-plated tube? I also think Generation makes a great Bb whistle, but maybe you got a flawed one (if that is what you have).

Maybe, I was too. My wife’s piano is just; however, it’s vintage. I do know that the vocalist’s I have worked with have preferred “just”.

I bought it new, and the paper packaging just said “Tin Whistle”. I dont remember what key it is in. It looks to me nickel, but it might be aluminum, I dunno. The mouthpiece is black plastic. The holes are not perfectly round, looks like they didnt to a to good of a job when making the holes.

Interesting. Just intonation with pure fifths etc. does make sense for vocals. As far as I know, ET equal temperament has been a piano tuning standard since the early 19th century, and the practical norm since the early 20th. Before that, it was various mean temperaments. But I know just and mean temperaments are sometimes applied to keyboards for playing earlier pre-Romantic repertoire, or for modern experimental pieces. Maybe yours is one of those.

I think my piano is in I-8 temperament. This is the special tuning that results from it bouncing around in a trailer on Interstate 8 between Phoenix and San Diego and never being retuned. :slight_smile:

Yikes! It sounds like you deserve a real whistle to match your interest. The one you have sounds like it’s a toy piece of you know what. For ~$10 US you can get yourself a nice Generation-style D whistle that can last you literally a lifetime. So go for it, then stick around Chiff & Fipple as you progress. Welcome aboard …

Yea, I figured it wasn’t much good, but I had heard that cheap tin whistles dont really mean crap.. in this case it prolly does heh. Thats kinda why I joined here, to see if either something can be done, or what should I try to go and get.

I can get a Feadog, or a Penny Whistle, but I dont know which one I should go wit. (they are both about the same price, and I want to try out a better whistle before spending too much, though the shipping prices for ebay really sucks).

[quote=“verdilak”]I can get a Feadog, or a Penny Whistle, but I dont know which one I should go wit.[quote]

when you say Penny Whistle is that what they are calling the brand?

I have Impempe D, Bb, C and F, all awesome. I like my Impempe even better than my Sindt, but that’s personal. I don’t know how the low D is. If I didn’t have a low D already, I would really consider it. Impempe is known to be soft, well my Sindt and Gens are much softer. Impempe is worth its price 3 times!! And Ian Turnbull is a very nice guy to deal with: he sent me a Bb only to try and swapped the F for me which had a mistake, and he has no waiting list.

Genereation is as a cheapie almost known for its well-sounding Bb. I put in a little putty and cleaned the inside of the plastic to make it smooth and now I’m also able to tune it. It has an awesome sound with a very strong bell-note.