Who knows? There is this bit in the description of the Kelpie.
Playability balanced towards beginners and intermediate players – making the the instrument more ‘accessible
What ever that may mean. Looks like a nice offering. It is certainly a good price for a well made low D as things go these days. So who’s got one of these to share their thoughts with us?
I’ve been wondering, too. Could it be…
Let’s take a continuum A<------------------->B
Approaching “B” we have whistles that do whatever you tell (or rather, blow) them to do. Advanced players will be able to express wonderful nuances with such whistles, but beginners will surely find all their shortcomings made patent (rather loudly, probably).
Approaching “A” we have whistles that have more a tendency to do their own thing, no matter what. Beginner players will benefit from the guiding tracks and probably will obtain more consistent results, while more advanced players are likely to feel somewhat constrained.
So, could it be that the “Playability balanced towards beginners” means a leftward shift in such continuum? But, more importantly , Please, please, please: what is the name for such continuum, and the proper terms for “A” and “B”? My brain is boiling…
I have to say that I’m a bit disappointed it’s another low D. Considering the hype and the lack of forthcoming info following the hype, I was hoping it would be another key, possibly another octave… another anything. Frankly, I would not consider the original design to be “less accessible” to a beginner in any way, other than price.
But the difference in price is significant, which I suspect will result in MK whistles getting in the hands of more people. And with the quality of MK whistles, that is a good thing.
Looks about right as it sits right now. I’d have considered a graphite model at £70, but for £100 I’m gonna pass. It would have been nice to have in the kayak this summer though.