I recently bought a wooden headjoint from Doc Jones made by Tony Dixon and am using it on my Dixon 3 piece polymer flute. As Doc advertized, it has a totally different sound and response as compared to when the poly head is on. For lack of a better term it is more ‘organic’, woody and I can ‘stick’ the low D much better. What has been the experience of others with ‘mixed’ flutes like this? Does it make a difference whether the body is wood and the head not versus the other way around?
The answer to this is very subjective on the Flute, player, type of wood, etc. I think most of us here can agree that even though it may sound really different to you, to a listener it may sound pretty similar.
I’d argue that the shape, chimney height, contour, and undercut of the embouchure matters a lot to the sound, and that therefore it wouldn’t be surprising that different heads sound different for these reasons. There is less agreement in general about other changes (resin versus wood, this wood vs that wood, lined vs unlined head). Many report that unlined heads sound woodier or darker, lined heads brighter and more focussed, but dissenting views are also heard. Lots of folks get modern flute makers to make heads for their antique flutes, and report that performance of the flute improves. I’d argue that changing heads is likely to change performance, but of course the direction of change isn’t necessarily for the better, and degree of change to a listener might be small as Avery has pointed out.
The headjoint–specifically the embouchure cut–is the most critical part of the flute for tone production; it has a profound effect on the tone and playability of an instrument. Trying three different heads–even by the same maker–on the same body is almost like playing three different flutes.
I wonder why that is. Is it because of the transmission of vibrations is different? For example, how my own voice sounds to me when I’m talking is different when I hear it in a recording.
I am not an expert, but the standard answer is that you hear yourself speak or play, partly through sounds carried through the air, and partly through bone, whereas others hear you only through sounds carried by air. I think another possibility is that some sounds will be audible to the player/speaker that won’t be audible to listeners, as sounds diminish in loudness rapidly as they travel from the source (I think this is an example of the inverse squares law, which says that loudness falls as 1 over the square of the distance, so a sound will be 1/4 as loud 2 feet away (1/2x2), and 1/16 as loud 4 feet away (1/4x4) etc).
I know when I play my whistle that the high octave notes may sound really shrieky and horrible to me, but to someone ten feet away they might sound perfectly clear (not that both my D whistle heads are cracked that’s changed, but…).
I once played a Water Weasel Ab whistle and to me it sounded pretty woody and rough, but to the owner a couple feet away it sounded really sweet and pure.
That wood headjoint is gonna give a way more complex sound due to the hand-work and the ‘graininess’ of the wood. The tone is really created before the sound is even 1" into the flute, so every nuance of that inch of flute is important.
That said, I just made a Delrin insert for a crappy old wooden headjoint, and it is much improved.
So you’re saying the tonal differences between flutes/headjoints should be discernable to both the player and the listener?
I guess an adjunct to my question is, what is actually vibrating? The air, headjoint (also the crown and/or stopping cork), the flute body? The lips, teeth, skull?
Or conversely, what’s dampening or filtering the vibrations? The key pads, the pads of my fingers?
I don’t know squat about physics, but it doesn’t seem to me any part of the flute can vibrate enough to put out a sound.
Come to think of it, I think the whole thing about flutes and whistles emitting sounds of any kind is a mass hallucination generated by the power of group suggestion.
It’s a bit mysterious and a subject of much controversy.
Still I think, as do a good number of others, that
the material the flute is made of does ‘color’ sound–
not that it’s the only factor. All other things being equal,
boxwood sounds different from blackwood sounds different
from rosewood sounds different from delrin sounds different
from brass sounds
different from silver (add ‘tends’ throughout).
Why this is so is unclear but my desperate guess is that
somehow the material IS vibrating, though heaven
knows where or how. I disbelieve that bore smoothness,
say, is the only difference–the molecular structure
of the material is more deeply implicated.
Many threads about this one…‘scientific experiments’
alleging to show the contrary…you name it.
Essentially, flute tone generation involves two components–the flute and the player. When I say the player, I really mean the player’s body–the resonating chamber the player produces: openness of the throat–even the resonance of the vocal chords, mouth cavity shape (largely what one uses to influence tone color), even the sinuses, to a degree (try playing with a cold), and of course the embouchure. Some of these can be influenced by the player, some can’t be. (So part of a player’s sound relates to skill, but another part is “built in.”) That’s why, skill levels aside, two players can play the same flute and sound different.
The flute basically holds a vibrating air column, the length and amplitude of which determines the note sounding. But the physical variables of a particular flute have an important influence on that vibrating air column: bore size and smoothness, tone hole size, wall thickness, and especially the embouchure cut (and all its related variables). Small changes to these can have big effects. That’s why two examples of the same model flute by the same maker are invariably slightly (or even not-so-slightly) different.
So you’re saying the tonal differences between flutes/headjoints should be discernable to both the player and the listener?
I think so. 90+% player, but there are differences.
I guess an adjunct to my question is, what is actually vibrating? The air, headjoint (also the crown and/or stopping cork), the flute body? The lips, teeth, skull?
Just the air, ideally. Anything that absorbes those vibrations is changing the volume or tone or both.
Come to think of it, I think the whole thing about flutes and whistles emitting sounds of any kind is a mass hallucination generated by the power of group suggestion.
I stress that I am over my depth here, as I am not a physicist. The sound is produced by the vibrating air column. The quality of the sound (presence of absence of overtones/harmonics) depends on the position and velocity, and shape of airstream relative to the lip of the embouchure that splits the airistream, and of the properties of the lip (undercut, depth, shape). It’s easy to hear the effect of changing the size and shape of the hole in your lips, the tension of your lips, and rolling the head joint in and out, so these factors must influence quality of the sound. Changing head joints does change the sound. There isn’t much debate about this part. The debate is whether the contributions of other things is big enough to matter given the importance of the things I’ve already mentioned.
Other things vibrate besides the air column (the stopper, the walls of the flute), but these are a waste of energy from the point of view of tone production. I don’t know, but I can imagine that the shape of the bore influences turbulence in the air column, which could influence overtones, but I don’t think this should depend on the material. I could also imagine that different materials polish to different degrees, and that too could influence turbulence in the air column, and thus sound. I can imagine that different materials vibrate or resonate differently, and that this could contribute to distortions in the sound that add character, but I would be surprised if this vibration contributes much of the sound (a few percent???).
I think the issue is whether these other possibilities are significant relative to the contribution made by the player and the embouchure itself. They might be real, but so small as to make no difference. Or they might be real, and make a difference. I don’t know myself. Common sense says that wherever there is a debate, the differences aren’t very big, otherwise there wouldn’t be a debate. I can tell birds from bats 100% of the time, but I am not always sure I can tell a Swainson’s thrush from a hermit thrush, and there are a whole lot of things in the “little brown bird” category that I don’t even pretend I can tell apart.
I think the experimental difficulty of testing the acoustic properties of different materials is ensuring that the different heads or flutes under test are identical except for the material, and in ensuring that the airstream used to test/calibrate the different materials is identical between flutes and tests. Tiny changes in the embouchure or airstream are likely to overwhelm the differences in materials. From the point of view of doing the statistics, random differences in airstream/embouchures could provide enough variation in the acoustic properties of each flute to make the contribution from the material hard/impossible to detect. In this case, the experimenter is going to conclude “no difference between materials”. The question is whether this means “there’s no difference” or “there is a difference but it is so small that we can ignore it” or “we can’t detect a difference owing to the difficulties of designing the experiment”.
Yeah, isolation of experimental variables, i.e., flute materials, dimensions, and variability in air stream, etc. is an age old problem. Wood in itself is unlikely to be acoustically isotropic, yielding slightly different resonant qualities depending on the grain, moisture content, finishes/oil or any other black magic treatments the maker may have subjected it to.
I have four different headjoints that all fit my flute. The original, two Jon Cs, and one from a baroque flute restored by Daniel Deitch, who recut the embouchure fairly big and round. The last one, I just discovered will fit last night. It’s the only one that sounds drastically different, and it’s suddenly my favorite. That could change tomorrow, though. So, the more the merrier.
No way, Tintin. You’re just downright wrong with your theories.
There’s just no way any body cavities resonations can affect the sound of flute or whistle. Think about it: the player only produces air stream and shapes and directs it and that’s all. After the air has escaped from player’s lips, it’s gone. There’s nothing resonating in the player’s body cavities or at least should not be with an exception if the player has been eating beans or something like that and even that kind of air resonance, though it may be audible, has no effect on the sound of the flute.
Well, they’re not “my theories,” although personal experience supports them. Like I said, try playing with a cold. Try throat tuning. Try changing tongue position. Try changing the shape of your mouth cavity while playing. All have an effect on tone. The player begins to shape the tone before the airstream even hits the flute. Despite your insinuation, I’m not talking out of my a**. Reading a variety of pedagogical material will make clear that these are not my ideas and that they have legitimate scientific and experiential basis.
Here are some related comments by Robert Dick (he taught at Boxwood a few years ago), who’s is a cutting edge (and deeply scientifically informed) virtuoso and innovator: http://www.larrykrantz.com/rdick.htm#ton