Rottenberg is a true Baroque flute, Grenser is more of a transition into Classical flute. Rotterberg will have a better first octave, Grenser will have a better third octave. If you want to be faithful to the period, you would use Rottenberg to play Bach, Telleman, etc, and Grenser to play Mozart.
Bore-wise, i’m not 100% sure, but i’d expect the Rottenberg to have a wider bore than the Grenser.
As long as I’m torturing myself…how “true” are the cross-fingered accidentals on these things? I mean do the accidentals sound anything like the open notes?
Part of the “charm” of a Baroque flute is that each note has its own distinct personality. The cross-fingered notes are more muted and weaker than the direct fingered notes, but they aren’t bad. The intonation can be tricky, but you can usually “lip” a note a full semitone up or down.
Well Eric, I generaly make love to that flute. I curl up in my little room, open the case, grab the turned grease pot, goop it up, put it together, and become totaly lost in the sweetness of her voice. And thats about all I can say on a family show.
Hey Chas; well right now I am a used up horse driver on the verge of passing out after another 12 hour day of being nice to tourists and trying to keep my two horses from ripping eachothers faces off. They are sick of each other. (two of the best looking, workingest guys it has ever been my pleasure to be aquainted with) But in 10 days it will be over and I will again have time on my hands. Oh glorious time. I can hardly wait. But now it is time for bed as I have another 4:30 am wakeup call. Take care
Tom
PS; Just to stay on topic, Lucs flutes are too good to be true. I still cant believe how much I enjoy playing old #13. What a sweetheart she is.
Thanks for the link to the new site Glauber,-it downloads so much quicker than Luc’s old site.
His work is indeed beautiful,and those prices are just so tempting!
However,I can’t justify another Flute,as I already have two Boxwood one keyed 19th C. instruments.
Yes. If it says it’s in 440 or A=440Hz, then it’s in modern tuning. If it says A=415, then it’s in “standard Baroque” tuning, or 1 semitone lower (all fingers down will sound C#).