I know, I know. Not my best work.
Trust me, I regret it already, especially having been caught using internet-speak in public. Oof.
Rob
I know, I know. Not my best work.
Trust me, I regret it already, especially having been caught using internet-speak in public. Oof.
Rob
Honestly, this feels like high school drama all over again.
We are all adults here, it isn’t that big of a deal if a thread gets locked. Have our lives really changed in some horrible way because of it? Don’t let it ruin your day.
ya wanna step outside and say that buddy?
OK, so Jimmy craic’ed quip, and got called. Let’s not lose two experts.
My leaning is toward thicker skins on the stick-puffers and steadier fingers on ye olde panic button, lest we all end up walking like Egyptians.
it is still a long way to spring ![]()
Believe it or not, the moderators want that. If we were perfect, I suppose we wouldn’t be here (if you don’t mind the tired cynical wisecrack chestnut). That said, I remain unconvinced that the proceedings that inspired this meta-thread were ill-handled, particularly as MTGuru’s illuminations on his purposes were perfectly reasonable to my mind. And strictly speaking, he didn’t have to explain himself. But who likes draconian? I mean, seriously. But obviously, this is a point of disagreement. Further on the other hand, others have (ungraciously, I think) called that merely the moderator having the last word.
Poor us. [← irony]
BTW, do note that we see this as worth discussing enough to not put a lock on (and, admittedly!) so far. So, no. No hieroglyphic fonts to download yet.
I’ve said this once publicly and at least once (I can’t remember - probably more) privately:
Since there are strong enough expressed opinions criticising the Mods in this case, I’d like to say - again - that I think they were spot on in this instance. If you other guys want a place that’s less civilised, and, frankly, plain agressive, then hop on over to the session.org. Plenty of flames there for you, with nary a Mod to bother you.
Me, I’ll enjoy myself around here where, with one or two exceptions, people are kind and thoughtful … 'cos there’s someone around to slap them if they’re not.
Yes, and I spent nearly two hours chipping an inch of ice from my car, and already it’s iced over again with strong winds, snow, and a possible tornado just beginning. I say, Come Sweet Spring.
What moderators?
not that I’ve a dog in the fight, but I don’t see that merely part.
If the last word is to be of any value it must be carefully worded to allow the other room to move.
Well if it is open to discussion, forums need censorship. Just a stream of thought, but…
There are objective reasons such as
Legal: Defamation, illegal porn, links to sites that promote illegal activities, etc.
Practical: Spam-bot removal, Vandles, etc.
And then there is the harder to police subjective reasons
Abusive: badgering people, unfair/uninformed criticism,
Continuity: This is taken care of here by having multiple music forms and a pub fore everything other than whistles, but other forums would kick your thread out the window for being OT, or delete posts that are OT.
Disruptive: A step down from vandalism (which provide no content) But a step up from the occasional OT comment.
Really, it’s not like this place is run by Robert’s rules of order.
Slashdot has a random system of choosing moderators and then random mod-moderators. It is really kind of democratic (not really a good thing) but it makes the moderation anonymous and yet keeps it in check. Unfortunately they can do that thanks to their size and readership, but C&F cannot.
Personally, I consider farewell threads as trying to get in the last word. Just leave if your going to.
Depends if I’m in charge.
On the positive side, we sure do have a passion around here for our music and our instruments. Gotta give us credit for that.
Since you say that you have no dog in the fight, I’ll take that to mean that you have no fundamental criticisms of how it was handled this time.
I would agree with you. Any time I have tried to offer a “closing argument”, my style is usually terse. I tend to lean on policy, especially where the the shades are not so gray. But you know what? That’s the easy stuff. Once the decision is reached, the main thing is to be as detached as one can. Doesn’t always work, but that’s the main thing.
Now, MTGuru’s was detached, but there was obviously a big heart behind it or he wouldn’t have taken such pains; that was one big load of ‘splainin’. But there were a load of issues that were best served with some explanation. Recognising that, I say it was well done, 'cause that’s NOT the easy stuff. AND it was easy to read, no mean feat.
Now to your issue with the word “merely”. Since I’m unsure of your drift, keep in mind that that has been a charge leveled by others. I don’t agree with it (of course). But it has been leveled. Maybe only a couple of times, but it stung. It stung because lording it is NOT the mod’s mission statement nor, as I believe evidence suggests, is it the modus operandi here. The good side is that things like that inspire the mods to examine ourselves. Could be worse.
Next, “allowing the other room to move”: I’m not sure what you mean. If by that you mean trying to preserve honor on both sides while doing the at-times unpleasant work of trying to correctly apply the policies of this board, even if it means putting the lock on, then yeah. I think we try. Do we accomplish it? Guess it depends on who’s talking.
oh, don’t be so defensive ![]()
I’m talking about the other’s perception.
oh, don’t be so defensive
You have to admit it was pretty detached, for defensive. ![]()
I’m talking about the other’s perception.
Gotcha.
it is still a long way to spring
In the motorcycle world we like to call it PMS. Parked Motorcycle Syndrome.
Cheers,
Kirk
I’ve ridden all winter. ![]()
San Joaquin valley and in western Washington.
The valley was much better,
the rain at freeway speed is not enjoyable.
While we’re having a civil discussion, here’s a thought of mine:
No one, short of a mod, has the right to order another participant to stop posting. Agree, disagree, but don’t try to simply shout someone down.
And before someone tries to accuse me of hypocrisy, let me point out that while I may be guilty of a lapse of decorum in trying to get someone off my back, I was merely protesting my right to post freely here so long as I don’t break the rules.
Rob
Rob, please…what did that have to do with being dumb enough to ride a motorcycle in the winter? ![]()
the rain at freeway speed is not enjoyable.
Just ride around Sequim for several hours.
Fluter-bikers?
Aaaargh!
That’s enough to scare anyone off! One insane (and generally non-life-threatening) obsession is enough for me! ![]()