'Lazy' reed problem

I recently started learning and making a chanter reed for my wide bore D chanter.

Main resource that I study is hegarty’s book.

Well, the result is I can make a ‘playable’ reed now, but all reeds that I made has same problem: they are ‘lazy’.

I’m not sure how to expression this, but I guess lazy is most appropriate term.

It is not hard to blow, or out of tune. But it just start slowly. I’m sure that it is not a ‘hard reed vs soft reed’ problem, cause my reed can sing under similar pressure to the reed that my pipemaker made for me, which is comfortably playable. But my reed simply require more pressure to start vibration. Once it start vibrate, following notes are played easily by droping the bag pressure.

I researched several resources but cannont find what is going on my reed.

I’will wating your advice.

I’m not an expert, but what I would recommend is sanding more at the edges of the reed close to the lips. Just slightly, but if you thin out behind those corners just a little bit, you might notice that “opens up” the sound of the reed a bit more. I’ve definitely experienced what you’re describing before, and that’s what works for my reeds and chanter.

Edges ‘near’ the lips (side of ‘V’), not lips, right? That’s interesting. I was trying thinning the whole upper 1/3 region, which eventually ruinning the reed. Thanks, I will try.

Correct, the very outermost edge of the ‘V’ near the lips. If the lips get thinned as well, that’s no big deal, they can be quite thin without problems usually. Just so that the corners don’t get sanded through!

Case solved. You’re right. More sanding was the answer. Thanks!!!

1 Like