Once again I’ve decided to put off replacing my reliable but boring Camry.
So instead, I scanned the expensive whistle page. Actually, I think it’s time for a new mid-priced whistle. I have several Burkes and play the brass black tip every day. I also have a Rosewood Busman that I play several times a week. I have the usual assortment of generations, susatos, oaks, feadogs etc.
As I scanned the reviews, I realized there are a bunch of high D whistles in $50-$100 range that I’ve never tried. The makers that caught my attention and Humphrey, Bartlett - Black Diamond, Parkhurst, Alba, Dixon, Silkstone and Reyburn.
I’d welcome any suggestions about what you like among these makers and why. Have I overlooked someone? My assumption is they are all good whistles, in tune etc. I also think it’s the players, not the makers, who can best describe their personalities.
I have a couple of Dave’s early whistles and like them. While I’m not looking for another one now, it’s interesting to watch the progress of his products, new materials etc. These are nice whistles and were an absolute steal at the early prices. While the prices are rising, it appears that the whistles are too. Good deal all around.
I re-read that review to see if the glowing endorsement was honeymoon induced. Well, I haven’t changed my mind - seven months (and several whistles) later and the review is not overstated (and my playing has improved).
Several whistles have gone through my stable since I bought the Reyburn. The two that always, and still, are in the top three played Sop D whistles are the Thin Weasel and the Reyburn. Accompanying them in the top three right now is a bumped and tarnished Burke Session Bore Brass from 2003 that I just picked up in a trade - it’s comfy like a pair of worn jeans.
I’d say, go for the Reyburn, and have a nice long chat with Ronaldo about exactly what you want.
My vote is for the Black Diamond High D, the only Whsitle I have that I liek more is a Sindt C. Of course Humphreys are supposed to be really good. I have an Alba High D that I am looking to sell at the lower end of your price range PM or email me if you want it. By the way Sindts are just at the top of your price range and you might like them, of course I prefer the BD to a Sindt D.
The sound is great! It’s crisp, pure, and strong up into the bottom of the third octive! The chiff is minimal as are the breath requirements. I just wish it was a little louder in the lower octive, I could barely hear myself at my last session. Now I wish Dixon would make a session whistle, then all would be right with the world.
So if you’re looking for a good solo wihstle, I’d recommend Dixon.
Don’t forget Granite Falls Manufacturing, Chuck Tilbury’s whistles. Medium priced but as good as high priced whistles I have tried. Wonderful precise intonation and even playing throughout the registers. And constantly improving.
