That is just the kind of info I was fishing for. It is amazing how much lift can be carried within octive and a second. My Copeland A has a new purpose. For my playing, actually, this will be it’s first purpose. If the third register A is in tune, I can play some octive-up variations like the fiddlers do. My Copeland’s A is fairly quiet so 3rd register A would not be a pain on the ears.
It is amazing how much lift can be carried within octive and a second.
Highland pipers know all about this…
My Copeland A has a new purpose.
Hey Mark, good thinking, thank you! You made me realize you can play the whole thing on an A whistle using E dorian and avoid having to fake or half-hole the G#s. Mind you the third part is a tad trickier.
Like you I am discovering uses for my A whistle. On the old board I posted notation for Lafferty’s Reel (aka The Glens of Aherlow) that I had transposed into A dorian from the usual E dorian, to allow me to get the low notes. The other night someone started this tune. After some calculation I realized that if I used my recently acquired A whistle I could join in using the “new” fingering, and felt very pleased with myself.