Identification request. Didn’t know where to post

Hello chiffandfipple community!! I have never heard of you guys so this will be my first induction into your wonderful group.

My apologies if I posted this on the wrong page, I am new here and this looked the most promising as it has the most active people.

i was directed here my a enthusiast on Reddit trying to help me with a problem.

For sake of length I will simply leave a link to my Reddit question if you would like to have it for context. https://www.reddit.com/r/Recorder/comments/1u1jh2b/why_wont_my_recorder_play_most_notes/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

This Reddit man has told me that it’s very likely my problem with being able to hit the higher notes cleanly on my instrument is because it it’s a recorder at all and thus recorder logic will not work on it.

Initially it was thought to be a toy made for tourists given it has evenly spaced holes which are all exactly the same size, but after realizing it’s actually tuned perfectly and plays a unique but clearly intentional note progression, he thought maybe someone here could identify what it is and tell me how to play it better. It sounds amazing in the lower notes but no matter what I do it sounds horrible or complexly cuts out in the upper notes.

Here is the approximate note progression going from lowest, to the highest properly working note.

D5 E5 F#5 G#5 Bb5

some of these may be slightly off as I used a phone tuner to identity them, but it said it’s perfectly tuned and you can hear it when it’s played. It sounds beautiful.

I think you got your answer on the other forum. No serious fipple flute (recorders and whistles are both fipple flutes) has evenly spaced holes of equal size, it just doesn’t happen.

Your “perfectly tuned” I think is imaginary.

Your trouble in actually playing it confirms that it is probably tourist item (“look it plays notes!”), or for children bought by un-discerning parents.