…aka your Generation D’s greatness may come from the most innocuous thing.
This is a cautionary tale.
I had a very good Gen brass D. Only needed the blu-tack tweak and the removing of the glue around the mouthpc to make it tunable. From responsiveness, easy playability, low breath requirements, everything was fine.
However, the tone was sometimes rough. I could have lived with it, because the roughness kind of went away when you’d played the whistle a while. I decided not to live with it.
I looked into the barrel and noticed a long white streak of dried excess glue running all the way down the length of the interior (where the holes were).
I decided this must be the source of the tone roughness. I removed the glue by placing the whole whistle in hot water, then gently scraping off the softened glue.
Result: I now have a nice clean barrel interior. The sound is no longer rough. BUT – the whistle is now a air/breath GUZZLER because the back pressure is now non-existent. Tunes that look hardly any air to play, I now run out of air in the middle of a phrase.
Argh. I really don’t get it. The excess glue seemed to have been the source of the back pressure on my Gen.
It’s still a nice whistle, but now it’s so much harder to play a tune on it without gasping for air at inappropriate times.
Try a little bees wax or PTFE tape around the upper rim of the body then put the head back on. It might be that it is leaking around the head since you took it off.
I didn’t immerse the mouthpc in the hot water, only the barrel. And I don’t think the water was hot enough to melt the plastic.
The mouthpc isn’t leaking. The removal of the mouthpc took place many months ago, and the whistle played fine. I’d noticed the excess glue then, but only decided to do something about it a few days ago. Like I said, it was one “tweak” too many.
On 2003-01-22 21:32, tuaz wrote:
I didn’t immerse the mouthpc in the hot water, only the barrel. And I don’t think the water was hot enough to melt the plastic.
The mouthpc isn’t leaking. The removal of the mouthpc took place many months ago, and the whistle played fine. I’d noticed the excess glue then, but only decided to do something about it a few days ago. Like I said, it was one “tweak” too many.
We’ve all done that, Tuaz. It’s just part of the learning experience.
Tuaz, even if you didn’t immerse the mouthpiece, if the mouthpiece was on the whistle when you immersed the tube and the tube got hot enough, that could affect the mouthpiece. There’s no harm in pulling the head off and trying the tape – since it can be so easily removed. I’d tamp down the blue tak, in case some minute change has happened there.
Hope something helps. I know how awful it is to mess up a whistle you like (though, so far, I’ve always been able to figure out a way to tweak it back into shape).
Good points, tkelly and ridsherd. Hopefully you’re right that it’s just leaking from the mouthpc seal. I’ll certainly examine the mouthpc very carefully.
To tell the truth, I was seriously considering trying to recreate the white streak of glue inside the barrel, even before TelegramSam’s posts!
The interesting thing about the glue streak was that it made a line right thru where the holes were. I noticed when removing the glue that a lot had built up around each hole on the internal surface (it didn’t show up on the outside). Since air does exit from the holes when you play notes other than D, that’s what got me wondering if the hole build-up had affected air resistance.
[ This Message was edited by: tuaz on 2003-01-23 04:20 ]
[ This Message was edited by: tuaz on 2003-01-23 04:20 ]
you know, tuaz, i would just leave it alone. yes, i know you’re more comfortable play with more resistance. but you still have a nice sounding whistle or so you say. And moreover, you should learn to subtley control the pressure on your own through your breathing. this will ultimately give you more versatility on the whistle. just my two cents. good luck with it.
OK, I’ve checked. I’m not sure. Maybe it’s slightly better. Or it could be my imagination. Either way, it still takes more air than it used to, but not so much that it’s unplayable.