I have a silly question

and it may even be OT ( :astonished: ) but the inquiring minds of the non whistle playing faction of Casa Izz want to know the answer. I have my own opinions, but who do YOU all think is the very best whistle player out there? I tried to convince them all that I am, but of course they didn’t buy it :laughing: Smart group I have here it seems :wink:
So, what are your answers?

I have a silly answer.

Slan,

D.

Now Dub, despite the fact that I’m asking a silly question, I’m still trying to ask an honest question. Besides, that picture really scares me :boggle:

Not to mention that I don’t think anyone will buy that answer either :laughing:

:laughing: :smiley: :laughing: :smiley:

I’d have to go for Joanie Madden myself.

Redwolf

Zamfir :smiling_imp:

Probably some little old fella who’s never left his own little area and never gets heard by anyone who would realise he’s the best in the world.

Could be close enough that one.

Well, you warned us about the silly question bit. maybe you are looking for a too definitive ā€˜best’.

It’s a bit hard giving an answer considering the number of fine whistleplayers we may not have heard.

I have a CD here that is about to be launched in a few weeks of MY favourite whistleplayer. Most of you won’t even know the name.

That sounds like me. Thanks.

tough question, i certainly don’t have an answer, all i can say is whose whistling i like a lot:

Brian Finnegan
Mike Mc Goldrick
Rory Campbell

to name but some..

edited for typo..

Aargh, Amar beat me to it. But only 'cos Brian’s bald as a coot.

because he shaves his head. :wink:

Which makes him go faster.

I wouldn’t really expect you to answer this and possibly give away the surprise, :laughing:, but is this player male or female?


I’m not that experienced at listening, but I would put in a word for Cathal McConnell. I have the first volume of his tutorial, and I have to say that what he does with some rather ā€œeasyā€ tunes made him stand out in my mind. He didn’t make them real fancy, but he turned them into music that I really could not imagine being any better.

Female. And I’ve sat in her kitchen and have played tunes in C with her. She on my Sindt C, Peter on his C set, and I on the old Walton C. :slight_smile:

Okay, I have a guess, but I won’t say it since it’s not a terribly educated one. Have come across about three mentions and a couple little photographs about the person I’m thinking of and heard a clip I believe. All indicated she is very special. Will be fun to see if I’m right.

because he prefers bald to peachfuzz! :laughing:

The best whistle player: I don’t know.

The best whistle tweaker: Jerry Freeman

The best whistle collector: JessieK

The best whistle photographer: Wanderer

Let’s not forget the Undisputed King of Internet Whistle Journalism: Dale.

Actually, I did dispute his status some time ago. Everybody seems to have forgotten though.