I Am Legend

Saw this yesterday, finally.
Wonder what people thought.

For those who haven’t it’s about a physician (Will Smith)
the only survivor in NYC three years after a
plague (a man-made cancer curing virus that
Smith helped engineer mutated into something
deadly) has wiped out most everybody.
The remain ‘survivors’ are rabid loonies who come
out only at night.

You mean the survivors are the populace of C&F? :smiley:

They’re not much into music, except
for Smith–he really likes Bob Marley.

It looks tempting. Will probably have to wait till it’s out on video.

haven’t seen it, but a friend of mine did; said there was a 6 minute Batman trailer before it… :smiley:

Yes there was.

My son said it was very scary–like horror movie scary. I hate horror movie type movies, but this looks intriguiing. I want to know whether I’d hate it.

I wonder if it follows the book any better than the Charlton Heston version did?

(I’m at work with an hour lunch and nothing much else to do - can you tell I’m bored at work today? :smiley: )

I saw it and enjoyed it.

It doesn’t follow the book, so don’t get your hopes up, there.

However, it is not quite your average “Would you like an arm with your brains combo” zombie flick either.

Will Smith does some fine acting in this one.

–James

Yes, I think it follows the book less well than
the Heston version did.

The scenes of NYC three years after the plague
are very good, very affecting. Also the terrible
loneliness of the Will Smith character,
who holds himself responsible for
the plague and is still determined
to find a cure.

Also the methodical arrangements he has made
to survive, both physically and emotionally.

I wasn’t sure Smith carried the movie so well–but obviously
most reviewers agree with James that he did
a fine job.

Will Smith has really come a long way from the whole “Fresh Prince” thing.

I’m not really wanting to see this one, however (not really my genre), but the oldest 3 can’t wait to go.

I will not see ‘The Golden Compass’. I have intelligence from those who have seen it that it is a flimsy travesty.

Tempted though I am by ‘Legend’, I fear it fecks unnecessarily with Matheson’s book. The story is sheer brilliance… but I hear the vampires have become ‘cannibals’, or some such bollox…

Why? Why change stuff? If you don’t like it, don’t make the fecking film.

Sorry. This stuff matters to me. Too many films fail because someone put in the extra work to ruin original source material that worked fine.

‘Blade Runner’ is the possible exception. Beats the crap out of Dick’s (good) book.

Hollywierd has an extremely poor record for making a viewable film from a good book. It seems like the better the original material, the harder they work to screw it up. Thoughtless people have difficulty putting out a thoughtful product.

I saw the movie yesterday with 2 of my sons, and enjoyed it quite a bit.
I didn’t read the book

I, too, was struck by the loneliness, his reliance on a routine, his relationship with his dog. I like Will Smith quite a bit.
I kept wondering what it would be like to be in that situation.

The ending was sad.
All in all, it provided a good afternoon out.

M

Yeah, it’s certainly worth seeing. Stayed with me too.
A good deal of it is character and situation driven,
and that’s what’s best. Toward the end it
becomes more of an action film, which is OK
but less good.
The end of the movie is alright but
the film’s strength is how this fellow
lives in those circumstances
day by day.

Some movies are better than the book.
‘All the Pretty Horses’ was better, IMO.
The novel had long parts where people told
a long story, went on for 12 pages or so.
This got cut appreciably in the move, of course,
and it made
a better story.

‘The Spy Who Came In From The Cold’
is better than the Carre novel, IMO.
A filmed spy-story can be very good
indeed.

I’ve never read the book, but I was a huge fan of “Omega Man” (which was itself only very loosely based on the book, if I recall) back in my babysitting days (late night TV in the mid-70s was inevitably either “Omega Man” or “Soylent Green”). I like Will Smith, so would like to see this updated version.

Redwolf

Went and saw the film…took my daughter, and she loved it.
There really wasn’t a great deal that they had to change to bring the story into the scope of a film. They did reverse the order on two major events (not giving out spoilers, so don’t anybody ask!!!) in the book, but the movie has better pacing than what it would if they’d just left it alone.
whoever told you it was a flimsy travesty needs to read more books that have been adapted for film, because by and large this adaptation was done fairly well (especially when compared to other ‘epic’ adventure type adaptations that have entire segments removed, major characters changed, merged or removed altogether etc)

Tempted though I am by ‘Legend’, I fear it fecks unnecessarily with Matheson’s book. The story is sheer brilliance… but I hear the vampires have become ‘cannibals’, or some such bollox…

Why? Why change stuff? If you don’t like it, don’t make the fecking film.

Sorry. This stuff matters to me. Too many films fail because someone put in the extra work to ruin original source material that worked fine.

‘Blade Runner’ is the possible exception. Beats the crap out of Dick’s (good) book.

You prolly hate the reimagined Battlestar Gallactica too, eh? :wink: :stuck_out_tongue:

Dude, there’s just some stuff that won’t work in a movie. There are some books that just move way to damn slow over certain parts to be filmable or include more information than can be efficiently delivered in dialogue over the course of, say, two hours (just using that as an arbitrary frame of reference, as it seems to be the average nowadays)
Films have to have a general pace and rhythm to them, and you eventually have to fit an abridged version of the story that (and lets be honest here) people will crucify you for cutting up no matter how good a job you, into a specific time frame and budget.
As far as adaptations go, The Golden Compass is a tad above average.
You wanna get into bad adaptations, have a peek at the first film from The Dark Is Rising series…They could change the title and the names and it would only be mild plagiarism.
As far as Blade Runner goes, i have to say I love the film…love it. i even bought the newest dvd version, even though I already have two.
Love it…but…it’s not a good adaptation of Dick’s work, plain and simple.
Having said that, Dick’s work doesn’t translate well in it’s true form to the screen, so, those of us who are Dick fans usually understand this going into any Dick-based film (with the exception of Next…lordy…please :stuck_out_tongue: ). On some subconscious level, we know what we’re going to see is going to be a rough adaptation of a Dick vision.
But you know what? It doesn’t bother me. Not at all.
Read the latest publication of Lies, Inc and tell me you could make a screenplay out of that. You’d have to be on drugs! But I’d bet the concept could be salvaged into a film.
True, some things maybe ought not to be made into films, but not everyone is on the same literacy level.
In the same vein, I’ve read books that I probably never would have before because I either saw the film it was based on or heard about it beforehand.
My nephew is a voracious reader for his age (9), and he often reads novels that were the inspiration for films he enjoys (i bought him his first copy of the complete Chronicles of Narnia for Christmas this year; beat the hell outta the Transformers he got from his parents).
When he sees a film he states quite matter-of-factly, “Now I’ll read the book…” and sometimes has to be told that there doesn’t exist a book for everything he sees on the screen.

jumpin judas fried chicken! look at the size of this post!!!
okay, sorry for the ramble.
Just wanna conclude with:
I for one love film adaptations of novels. I love the art of trasfering from one story-telling medium to the other; I love the science involved in that transfer as well as the creative portions…

and the armored bears kicked ass. :stuck_out_tongue:

I saw it and liked it for the reasons mentioned. I thought Smith did a good job.

I have no use for horror films at all…never go see them or rent them.

This was markedly less gross and horrible than it could have been. I was proud of them for not taking the easy way out.


Also saw Golden compass which I thought was a snore-fest. I found myself wondering why (before spending a gazillion dollars on special effects) they didn’t spend $75 dollars on an English major to read the script and see if there was a story there…oops.

Doc

Great post, mate.

I’m an obsessive reader and an obsessive movie nut - to the extent of arguing in the office this morning about screen aspect-ratio formats and the awful pan/scan mess that many TV companies make of movies they show for a market still largely coping with 4:3…

DON’T BE AFRAID OF THE BLACK BARS, GUYS. Sit closer to the TV - letterbox is your friend… Sorry, whole other issue…

The feedback I have got so far about the Pullman adaptation is from a couple of critics I have found very sharp in the past: my colleague Stanley, who is the most awe-inspiring authority on cinema I’ve ever known. The other is my youngest daughter - a Pullman fan who is doing a degree in film.

That said - my daughter doesn’t like Blade Runner (so is demonstrably not infallible), and Stan hasn’t read the Pullman original. Yours is the first considered positive review I’ve seen from someone who knows the book. I’m intrigued enough to give it a go - when it hits DVD - which is more than I was before reading your post.

Actually, I quite like the new BSG! Better than the original, which I always thought was an absolute load of sub-Star Wars, fetid dingo’s kidneys.

I’m also a big PKD fan, but I personally think that Blade Runner as a movie worked better than …Androids… does in print. I know it’s pretty much a different story and I don’t have a problem with taking the inspiration in other directions - if it is necessary to make the translation work.

Did anyone ever try to film Palmer Eldritch? Now that would be quite a job for any screenwriter…

As for Legion… we’ll see. I do like Will Smith, and I think the Movie version of Asimov’s I Robot was decent enough.

I know adaptation is not easy - I’m a writer myself and have mates who have adapted stuff for film and TV - but there’s a difference between making changes to ensure a successful translation from one medium to another and making gratuitous, fashionable changes to a concept that worked fine and risking serious damage to a central metaphor.

To me (admittedly without having yet seen the movie), the change from vampires to cannibals (or indeed from vampires to anything) risks missing the crucial swapping of situations/roles, and realisation thereof, that is the main gag in the whole of Matheson’s brilliant fable.

The book, to me, simply cries out for a faithful(ish) movie treatment.

You think that movies leave out a lot, check out some of Waterhouse’s paintings. ‘The Lady of Shallott’ is nothing like the poem.

(Sorry, just feeling a bit silly this morning.)