How serious are we about practicing?

I’ve been playing flute for 6 months. As a beginner I have no option but to practice every day if I want to progress. Fortunately I enjoy practice time and find no problem with commitment and discipline but have to agree with the previous comment that quality is what matters. Regular, structured, intelligently focused and efficient practice is what delivers progress not simply the duration of practice.

My daily practice is currently 30-40 minutes and I find that the time I can maintain the necessary focus has gradually increased. We fool only ourselves that we’re benefiting if we keep on pushing beyond the point where we lose focus.

In truth I never stop practicing. I keep a cheap old Gen on me pretty much constantly and my fidgeting takes the form of practicing tunes via the “air whistle” effect. I’ve learned more tunes at my desk at work than in my studio!

My commitment has been to play EVERY DAY, even if that’s just 10 minutes (or even less than that at times). Over the last 10 years, I have missed very few days. 30 minutes is probably my average. There are times when I’ll play for hours if at a camp or have lots of gigs. Usually the most I’ll play is an hour or 2. Bottom line, I think it’s critical to play every day because flute (or any instrument played at a high level) takes the coordination of very fine motor skills, muscle control, breath control, etc. that only daily practice/playing can achieve.

PS I avoid playing whistle. It adversely affects my flute embouchure and takes away from time on flute. Playing whistle may be useful for learning tunes, but it does not improve flute playing. Two very different instruments.

I completely agree. I’ve heard people argue otherwise, but I find the exact same thing you mention, so I usually avoid whistle as well, unless I’m sitting in front of the telly picking away at some half-remembered tune. Somehow, in my mind, that doesn’t count.

Also, practicing with tuner and metronome are essential for me to improve my intonation and timing. Gots to play in tune and in time.

I can see why this would be important, Akiba, if you play with others. I don’t. My enchantment is with the sound of the flute so I look for a tune’s meaning with whatever key, timing, volume, ornamentation, and phrasing that gets that. It’s like reading purposeful ryhming poetry aloud in a way that penetrates the tingle and awe of it’s meaning, but in powerfully ephiphanous flute sounds. Other people’s interpretations and technical disciplines can be a distraction in my case.

Best wishes, Keith.

All right, then. Sounds noble. Carry on…