Yes, they’re pretty fragile. I cracked the headpiece of my composite low E once. I was carrying it in a backpack (dumb, dumb, dumb) and leaned against something. Now I keep it in a hard case.
Oh my. After reading this thread, I wonder if I should try to find a hard case for my new D/C set. I received them from Pat O’Riordan in August and have been taking them almost everywhere with me. (They’re blackwood…sooo beautiful. He is such an artist.)
Hi Starr! Still bummed we weren’t able to hook-up when I was in St. Louis a few years ago. I haven’t been back since.
Your Pat O’s should be fine travelling with you during the mild months of the year, just don’t leave them in a hot car in the summer, and I’d think twice about taking them out and about in the winter if you can’t either keep them warm, or allow them to slowly adjust to colder weather and then back to room temps - playing cold wooden whistles/flutes, or taking warm (just played) instruments out into the cold, even in a case, can lead to cracks I’m afraid.
Pat makes wonderful whistles (I miss the set I had), enjoy!
Hi, Falkbeer, I’ve never played an aluminum Burke. I do have a brass Burke, which is very nice, but I wanted the quieter sound of the composite for practicing around the house. It may also be useful when I’m playing with friends on tunes I’m still learning.
I think the quieter noise level is working out. I’ve gotten fewer “Can you give it a break?” requests from the family. It’s also very pretty sounding and extremely easy to play.
But if I was going to have just one, I think I’d choose the brass. I like the way feels in the hands a little better. This is probably an emotional rather than rational thing. In my head, at least, the brass one comes closer to my own ill-conceived ideal of whistleness.
Yes!!! Yes yes YEEESSSS. O’Riordans are not readily available, and Pat’s not taking orders. You mess those up and you’ll be kicking yourself for many years to come… find some kind of a hard case, please… either that or send them to me and I’ll put them in storage for you (heh heh heh…)
As many have said, the Burke composite narrow bore is relatively quiet. My first experience with it in a session is that it’s hard to hear myself playing. I’m also making some ugly noises, probably because I’m overblowing it in trying to play louder. Obviously, I’m not totally in control of the whistle yet, but I’m pretty sure that this won’t be my top choice for a session whistle.
I do really enjoy playing it at home.
Hmm. Different whistles for different purposes… sounds like an excuse to buy more whistles, doesn’t it?!
Now that an acceptable level of thread drift has set in, I can safely make the post that I immediately thought of when I saw the title: same as for any whistle - leave it out in the open somewhere that you frequently pass by, and give it a tootle every time you see it.