Guinness in Flutes

Hey folks,
Once saw an Irish fellow pour some Guinness into his flute and shake it around saying it was “thirsty”.
Seemed like a bad idea at the time, but he was a great player.
Is there anything behind this or was he just being silly?

Just being silly. I wouldn’t recommend doing this to your flute. Besides, why would you want to pour the Guinness in a flute instead of your mouth! :smiley:

Well you know, if the flute has a small crack or two and moisture’s gonna make the wood swell, thus closing the crack … and it sure would be faster than playing the thing for 40 minutes …

Yep. I’ve heard of it, talked to people who’ve seen it deployed (one of whom has also witnessed the alternative garden-hose-of-water technique) more than once, thought about it, and have certainly been tempted.

But I haven’t done it, and hopefully I won’t.

(Though one of my flutes has nearly driven me to it.)

BTW, FWIW, in Timber: A Flute Tutor, Fintan Vallely recommends against it.

However it could be for tightening the cork by making it swell up, I used to pour warm to hot water into my metal piccolo because it did’nt get a lot of use, worked every time, also I used to use cold water on a wood fife which never cracked (a cheapo so I really did’nt care much) it was probably maple.

Indeed it is done, was done and will be done. Why? No idea. I often throw a few gallons through my home made tootlers to clean em out and notice they play much better when wet. Again I have no idea why?

Free reed all don’t like being played cold. That one is as old as I am and more. I used see the old timers warm up the Box by leaving in the case by the ‘range’ for a while before getting it out to play.

It works great provided the player acts as a filter:
Guinness => Player => Flute.

Cheers,
Aaron

Maybe great for the player, not so sure about the people listening.

No problem as long as those listening utilize the same treatment :smiley:

Yo Brian, what session do you hang out at?

Don’t. Been meaning to get to O’Connells or Paddy’s, but just never get the chance.

“You can’t really buy beer, only rent it”. – Archie Bunker

The closest my flute gets to having any Guinness is when I burp into it. :smiley:

The closest my flute gets to having any Guinness is when I burp into it.

Some time ago I noticed an interesting burping into flute/whistle during a tune phenomenon. The pitch changes… sometimes dramatically! It is particularly noticable on a whistle (small air column). I suppose this is because the density of a burp is different than that of an exhalation. Those of us who are of a scientific nature might want to test the relative pitch changes produced by Ginness burps vs. say a soda.

Fortunately I only notice this at home because I don’t drink during gigs. The more I drink the better my playing… in my own mind alone. Everyone else just looks at me quizically after each tune as though to say “What were you doing on that one?”

Clark

I believe I read that when you burp, the amount of carbon dioxide in your exhalate increases dramatically. This change in the mix of gasses causes the pitch to drop momentarily because this mixture of gasses vibrates differently than your normal exhalation does.

As for pouring liquid down the bore of a wooden flute, I’d say don’t do it. You can, of course, do that to a polymer flute any time you like, but I’m not sure it would gain you anything. :slight_smile:

Best wishes,

–James

I remember how Guinness-fueled “eructations” would almost completely mute my tone momentarily. I just chalked it up to the nitrogen. Funny thing is, that doesn’t seem to happen any more for me. Embouchure, perhaps? And no, I don’t drink enough Guinness to have changed me to a nitrogen-based life form, although I have consumed enough to wonder that I never got the bends.