One wonders whether the rules of grammar and style came before or were afterward influenced by Jane Austen.
“I see the similarity” is a statement made by me, about me and my vision.
“one sees a similarity” avoids the individual specificity and at least leaves open the possibility of the the sentiment being generally held or generally accepted by a group. Could be polite. Could be slippery. Could be both.
It’s funny, but it also kind of forces the point into the burlesque with the very first example. Our language seems to have ways around everything. In order to render passive voice with acceptable grace and communicate the above scenario fully enough, you might go about it like this: Because the computer couldn’t be programmed by anyone present, we were forced to quit.
Honestly, I was unaware of the general stylistic rule of thumb proscribing passive voice. My sins must be enormous.
I try not to let all this stuff bug me… I was accused publicly on Facebook of being a Grammar Nazi. I prefer the term Grammar Geek. I don’t go around correcting people, unless they are in English class and I’m their teacher. That was a fun couple of years
I like the suggestion in this article that we use the energy to learn another language. My French is pretty good. I took a course in introductory Japanese - fun but difficult - and I would like to learn Irish.
I find this sentence to be quite interesting. The choice of words is specifically meant to show a lack of proper grammar but you included the apostrophe on knowin’. Yet despite that small accolade to somewhat proper grammar you left out the apostrophe in y’all. Hopefully my head will not literally burst into smoldering pieces as I contemplate that.
(I have never been as conscious of my grammar as I was whilst writing that short paragraph, and even with that I probably messed it up somewhere)
Actually, not your bad at all. Unlike Simon’s nuanced distinction above, the details of the writing system are definitely not grammar. That is, the organizing rules of a language are independent of its graphemic representation, though there may be mappings between the two. Writing systems (orthographies) do have rules, of course, but those are not grammar rules. A common confusion.
You didn’t have Miss Cook for 12th grade AP English. That’s all. Had you gotten every essay returned with notations such as “PV” all over it in red, you’d have a visceral response to passive voice that would last the rest of your life.
All I know is that my assistant’s last name is Grammer which means I am now doomed to misspell “grammar” at least half the time for the rest of my life.
This was the closest that I could come to a picture on the internet of Miss Poorbaugh who taught English/Creative Writing to my Mom and all my Brothers. The Passive Voice is evil.
Lacking Miss Cook, I have this thread. For some reason it has made an impact that public education never did; my come-to-Jesus moment, if you will. I don’t know if I’ll have your visceral response, but I WILL be far more aware of it. Which is not to say that I’ll abandon PV on general principles, because that runs against my grain. If it exists in our language, then it has uses, and I’d rather remember, retain, and employ it where appropriate for any practical as well as occasionally stylistic reasons. But then I’ve never had a problem dancing with the Devil. Sometimes I’ve made a point of it (and, to be honest, I’ve always found something likeable about PV, so we’ll see how that goes).
It’s a dead giveaway that the speaker is avoiding something. If someone’s telling you an account of something or other, pay attention when they drop into the passive voice for a sentence or two. That’ll be where the bombs are hidden or the bodies or buried.
You see … That’s where a lifetime of fussing about prescriptive grammar will get you. Though, of course, that’s where a lifetime of anything will get you.
I am sew glad I is unfeathered by the gramadrigal rouxs that oppress all of youse. I literaturely play no attendance two them. Lucky fer me I married into language…
Maybe it’s because I came to read and love books by Jane Austen late in life, but I have this mental association between PV and notions of Anglican propriety… sort of like the “e” at the end of Pointe. No hypotaxis (muted subtext) intended… [I just had to use that word !]
I read a book once titled “Confessions of a PR flak”, written by a retired public relations executive. He explained that when hiring, he looked for people who could write “muscular prose”. I think PV is the opposite of muscular prose.
I must say though, with words like hypotaxis, graphemic, and orthographies, this thread has been… novel !
I remember reading a series of grammar rules by Gore Vidal, I think it was.
It began:
“The Passive Voice should not be used.
A preposition is a bad thing to end a sentence with.”
Can’t recall the rest, but it was a fine example of taking the rules with a pinch of salt. Still, it’s worth remembering the word “figuratively”.