By the way, any opinions on the Reyburn LB C? I’ve got dibs on a D/C LB set.
What about a Jerry Tweaked Shaw or Walton’s C? They’re probably better than a Susato at a reasonable price.
I’ve not had good luck on one occasion with a Copeland C and Jim acknowledged that they had had problems in that key; although that was some time ago and he thinks they have it under control now. It’s the only key missing from my Copeland set and I guess I remain a bit gun shy. Maybe next birthday. ![]()
PhilO
By the way, any opinions on the Reyburn LB C? I’ve got dibs on a D/C LB set.
That’s what I thought about, when asking if you were after CM or Dm… Maybe all you need is an extra D tube with a minor scale, i.e. natural F, and if an F# is needed, you can always half-hole the G.
That’s what Hiro got from RR for his Sindt heads… See http://chiffboard.mati.ca/viewtopic.php?t=13256
To see if it can work with you, you may experiment by taping the higher two thirds of the F# hole on a standard whistle.
Depending on the precise type of “minor” D you play you may need the occasional Bb for harmonic or Eolian-- no big deal.
That particular Copeland is going with me to the grave, unless my kids turn out to be REALLY nice.
She’s not kidding Glauber, I’ve tried and tried to get that whistle back - to no avail, so don’t even bother. I don’t think she’d sell it even for a grand, which I’d actually consider paying, because that thing is so damn good.
I never should have parted with it.
(Waaaaa! whining makes me feel better, hee hee.)
Loren
Yes, i gave up on that one. I have very little chance of outliving Jessie.
![]()
Many thanks to all who responded! My answer ended up being… none of the above! A D/C Reyburn set came up for sale for a good price and i bought it. Hopefully it will do the trick. But i will keep the Copelands, Burkes, Thin Weasels and the others in mind.
I’m sure JessieK did post a reply. Then it vanished in the ether. I know I should stop white wine with crabs: crabmeat makes me see strange things. Meanwhile…
It suddenly struck me no-one mentioned Dave Parkhurst’s high whistles.
Superb whistles, truly handmade and at a steal price given the work and sound…
Funny how brands here get hyped or disdained through fad cycles.
Reyburn’s high C is very nice, as is Abell’s. I have a Jerry-tweaked Shaw C that’s quite fun to play as well.
My Reyburn C is part of my raffle prize . . . I got the D/C set with an extra D tube. (Thanks Reynaldo!)
Stuart