You must be as old as me Denny.lol I was on the CV62 USS Independance.
Odd little world out there. ![]()
I’d take the flute to the foc’sle to practice.
Sitting for hours thinkin’
“I’ve seen girls 5’1” tall & 93# playin’ these suckers
it can’t be that hard." ![]()
Maybe try learning a few simple melodies that the people who have to listen to you practice like? Whatever, pop songs, show tunes, classical bits. You don’t have to play them fast or flashy, just simple, fun, and even.
Does your building has a boiler room or laundry room or some other noisy place? Perhaps an hour or half hour spent in there would be ok?
Maybe try learning a few simple melodies that the people who have to listen to you practice like? Whatever, pop songs, show tunes, classical bits. You don’t have to play them fast or flashy, just simple, fun, and even.
This is what I was going to suggest.
It’s hard for people to enjoy music that is unfamiliar. Although I love the sound of the irish whistle and irish flute, I have to say, ITM just doesn’t interest me in the least. I like slow airs. Every time I listen to a recording that one of you posts, I’m always disappointed that it’s ITM again.
It’s easy for people to enjoy music that they know. Add some of “their” songs to your list of tunes. Pretty soon one of those songs is going to hit one of your neighbors right in the heart. Folks might even ask for requests.
It’s also very easy for people to complain about the practicing but that’s one of the things that makes your building special. I bet if you didn’t play, people would fuss that you’re not playing now. I don’t think many of those people really mean it as deeply as you may think.
GOOD - I’ve been playing whistle for about a year too and I’m not nearly that good. Your playing made me happy. But, you are doing something wrong…you’re playing to the wrong audience. Find like minded souls and you’ll get a better response. On the website “WhistleThis” one person submitted a recording of a tune without the fipple on the tube of his whistle; he was just blowing across the tube. It was cool, very breathy but you could still here the melody, the ornaments, etc. Whistling without the whistle sound part…maybe worth giving a try if you can’t get away by yourself…kbr
Well, there’s something about whistles (& ocarinas) that makes them so fun to PLAY but maybe not always that much fun to listen to.
Also, some people just don’t like music very much! – My husband, for one! I just love it when my boys are playing either the guitar or the bass or the piano or the organ, & my husband just pretty much wants them to stop the second they start. Maybe it has to do with not being able to control what (or when) music is being played. I know that can be an annoyance sometimes.
I enjoyed the clip you showed us on Youtube, and see that you already have a mellow whistle. However, if you have a lot of money, you could buy a Burke whistle, which would probably be pleasing to more ears. Or if you had a little money, you could buy a traditional Clarke whistle which is pretty & soft & not so strident as many tinwhistles.
But mainly just try to remember the joy you feel when you play. That’s the best. If others like it, that’s great, but if they don’t–well, sometimes you must play anyway, for yourself.
Hi there,
A few anomalies here i think.
You say from your first post, your playing isn’t that bad, then you say in a following post, you understand your music isn’t worth listening to!
The only way to deal with this is for you to decide how much you want to play. If your desire or hunger to learn is leaning more towards keeping going than giving up then that’s what you have to do.
Where theres a will theres a way type thing.
btw how long do you practice for each day? What does your practice routine / schedule consist of? How do you develop your tone?
Musicians have to make sacrifices to learn their craft.
If it’s a question of my desire against other peoples influence then my desire wins I’m afraid. I can be quite selfish about this but that’s ok cos I’m a musician…
pkev
I get crap from other people every day, just keep practicing, and you will WOW everyone in the pub one day.
I am listening to your clip right now. You play fine and it is very enjoyable. Maybe you should just feel sorry for anyone complaining because they obviously just don’t “get it”. Their world is less for that. You get enjoyment from playing. You do a good job of it. Don’t you dare stop!
I love my whistle, but I’m not sure doing something that irritates everyone is something that is worth doing. And I don’t know how to deal with that.[/quote]
It is worth doing. Don’t let people who don’t understand discourage you. Be as considerate as you possibly can, but don’t let them discourage you. Practicing isn’t always the pretty part; it isn’t supposed to be, that’s why they call it practice. I listened to your playing and found it delightful. That kind of playing is the reward of practice. If you can persevere in your challenging surroundings, please do so. Having a passion for the pennywhistle is a strange and wonderful thing, and the world would be a poorer place without you playing whistle in it.
Maybe your parents or brother or neighbors…SOMEBODY…has a car, or truck, or bus or shed or or or
SOMETHING you could practice in. That way, they wouldn’t have to listen to you…and you could play to your heart’s content.
If you really want to learn to whistle…find a way! Good Luck.
I feel your pain. I also love playing my whistle, but just when I think I’m getting somewhere, I realize everyone has left the room. My husband, who has listened carefully from day one, is the only person who seems to appreciate my playing.
I also found that when I (reluctantly) played for a friend who sometimes plays in an Irish band, he thought I was doing very well indeed, so the suggestion to find a new audience is probably a good one. The music is not for everyone.
Lastly, a few days ago my spouse and I visted a coffee house where an “Irish” band was playing. The woman who played the whiste (and a very good flute) was able to play the whistle with perfect accuracy, timing, and tone. But it did not sound like an Irish whistle. She used no ornamentation, played with no expression, and obviously had no clue what real Irish music sounds like. She was pretty much just playing it like the flute and it was flat and lifeless. I know I can do better than that. It was an eye-opener. If you love the music in its traditional form, it will show when you play.
Breqwas,
Really like your playing too… So don’t quit ! But I get this from my wife and kids, too… I’ve been banished to the garage for practice. Can’t say I blame them. I sometimes play in the car or in the park… and behind the reception of the hotel I run. Guests sometimes look funny to find out where the “music” comes from but most are sympathetic.
Maybe there’s a school closeby, or a church, monastery… A pub that has a room above… Public toilets ?
Don’t play any George Michael songs there ![]()
I’ve seen pictures of your session. Maybe that pub has a place for you ?
And if all this fails, maybe invest in the technopipes other forummembers have suggested…