Getting the hard, dark, tone

And then they’re home, and it’s awkward, they way they just stand there, staring, chewing, listening…




R

takes a large bath, it does

Ah. We’re well and truly in hot air territory now! And wet to boot! (Need boots with all that humidity and the cows…) Just remember, we don’t want to get into hot water (as well) now, do we?

This is also represented in a scene in the very old “Little Rascals” series, although I think remembering this shows my age.

Since we are off-topic, I’ll come back on the lemons business. It may be a myth, but I reckon it predates ‘Lentil’. I heard it from my grandfather in the late 50’s by way of explanation of a joking cryptic comment - “I’ll be along with my lemon” - made by another old guy to a third old guy, a brass player who was going to ‘do a turn’ at some event.

Thanks for the summary Terry, though I think you have said it all here before. And I’ll re-read the extracts you link next time I have an ‘embouchure review’ to check I have not got stuck in bad ways.

However - going through the video clips of players whos tone I like, especially on the comhaltas site where I assume they producing an ‘irish’ tone, I wouldn’t describe what I see as frowning, more as ‘corners of mouth tucked back and maybe a little down’. My impression is the lips are usually free from the front teeth (not tight as in a smile but not pouting). Is that right ?

Terry-

A million thanks! I had heard some mention about blowing down into the hole, but until now I have been working on my emboucher (without a teacher) by trying to focus a smaller stream of air across the hole.

Your article was the perfect exlanation at the right time for me. I am getting a better tone with less air and less effort. My low D is more solid and dependable. And my upper register is sweeter and clearer. I still have a long way to go, but now at least I’m headed in the right direction.

y-nought

Very good, y-nought. I’ll send you an invoice for the consultancy services!

Now on the lemon story, doesn’t it date back to the 18th century? Along these lines: A composer was working in the front room of his house when the country band set up outside his house to busk. The composer soon found he could not concentrate on his music while that infernal rackett was going on. Noting that the band leader was a flute player, he paid a small boy sixpence to stand in front of the flute player and suck a lemon noisily. The band soon moved on.

I’ve seen an engraving of what could be a related image - perhaps someone else knows of it. It shows a gentleman arguing through his window with a band member.

Terry

Thanks Terry, I thought I had a pretty good tone until now… I read your article picked up my flute and lo and behold I had a totally new instrument. I’m hitting the sweet spot everytime now. No endless fiddling about with my lips! :thumbsup:

I think it’s safest to regard the stuff I wrote as a “first approximation” - a general direction to head in. Once you get safely away from blowing at the edge and smiling intensely, there are probably a lot of other variations to try out, always keeping in mind the differences between peoples’ construction and the differences in peoples’ tastes.

The first approximation might be all I need, with my scientist’s hat on, to seek to explain the generality of why Irish players and 19th century English performers sound so different to modern classical players, even if playing the same flute. But your job as a player is to seek out any further possible improvements, for your own increased enjoyment and the benefit of those listening.

Even so, I’ll be sitting here in the back seat, watching where you’re all driving, in case some new twist or turn demands a “why is it so” response!

Heh heh, anyone remember Professor Julius Sumner Miller? I can hear his harsh Bostonian accent even now. “Why cloud the charm of a Chladni plate with a Bessel function?” They don’t write stuff like that any more!

Terry

one should never fiddle with their lips…

keep yer teeth of the guitar strings also :really:

If we’re thinking about the same one, it’s by Wm. Hogarth, and called “The Enraged Musician”. Basically the man in the window is a more gentlemanly sort, well-heeled or undoubtedly with patronage if he is solely a musician, with tortured look on his face as he holds his hands to his ears and/or tears his hair out. There is a bow in his right hand, and a viol of some sort propped improbably in the open the window under his right elbow. There is a dirty, scruffy street musician (lone, as I take it: see below) playing a shawm or hautboy under his window and the apparent focus of his rage. The whole street part of the scene is elbow-to-elbow with hawkers, knife sharpeners, errand-girls, mounted grandees, etc; you can almost hear the chaos, so one musician focusing on another amid the noise argues for a fair amount of irony on Hogarth’s part.

There is, at a slight remove from the street musician, a child (I’d place him at about six years) banging on a drum, but he is off in his own world (Lord, that sounds familiar :wink: ), is himself bewigged, clean, far better-dressed and better-nourished than the street musician, and has a toy wooden sword made of slats, so my money’s on him being from better resources and is just outdoors playing military as boys can be wont to do, and not part of a band, but just another part of the general uproar. The only figures with any obvious musical aspect are the man in the window, the street musician, and the child. Well, there’s a fellow on a horse in the background blowing a calling-horn, but I don’t count that. :slight_smile:

Also under the window is a charming little sub-vignette of a 3/4 back view of a male child of modest means intent on the business of taking a leak in the street with no care for anything or anyone, and before him is a well-dressed little girl with a ratchet noisemaker. The expression on her face is priceless.

I was hoping to post an image, but all the sources I find have antitheft copyrighting marks on them, and I don’t want to get C&F into trouble. So, just Google the relevant keywords, and you’ll find it, no problemo.

Wiki sez its public domain :smiling_imp: although I did like yer description!

The above is a rather different variation on the ones I’d looked at; while the layout is generally the same, the details are different enough. In your version the child has a Hussar’s hat, whereas in mine, only a periwig. The lady with the tub on her head has in my version a smile directed at the viewer, the man in the window’s expression is not at all so vague, and the young tyke doing his business is more obvious for it. Also yours has no mounted hornblower.

Something strikes me that either the one I was describing is an original, and the Wiki one is a remake by another artist - this was done, a not uncommon practice - or it’s vice-versa. While I’m no expert, much less on Hogarth, they don’t look technically alike enough to me to believe they both come from the same artist’s hand, and the level of shadowing in your version is heavier, of a different style as well, I think.

But we WERE talking about a hard, dark tone, weren’t we. :wink:

Howzat fer segueing gracefully back on-topic? :smiley:

very funny. lol. and I did do the cig in the mouth one time, but I was playing whistle… it worked quite perfectly. then I quit. haha.

if I were literate I might have read the feckin’ page…

the other one is an earlier variation…

ah, anyone that can read here

Nope. Not the same one. Much closer, though.

Try this link, and click to enlarge.

I’m sure that we all have had troubled times in our youth…

We’re older now & more responsible.

And we don’t get caught as often…

oh, okay…you read the wiki I linked though

No, I did NOT. I went to Google and typed in “hogarth prints” (who needs caps?) and did a little looking, which was, like, none worth talking about.

I’m a purist. So there. :stuck_out_tongue:

Art.com? is that affiliated with “We B Art”? :poke:

I meant that I’d go look at yer picture while you read the Wiki article…