How many attempts does it usually take to make reeds?
Impossible to say, though I guess with increasing experience you eliminate more of the variables as you gain more control over them.
I see you have yet to receive your first chanter. I would suggest spending a little time getting used to the mechanics of the instrument before worrying too much about reedmaking..keep it as a medium term aim and make sure you get a couple of spares from your maker!
Since it’s really dry here, should I just do the sponge bellows technique?
If the humidity is constantly low, just get your reedmaker to make a set of reeds for dry conditions.
How many licks does it take to get to the tootsie roll center of a tootsie roll pop?
Starting out, I failed a lot. This was mostly owing to not actually seeing it done in person and getting that face-to-face time with a pipemaker. As long as you follow some basic principles, and don’t rush, you can make a good reed almost every attempt (mileage may vary).
If you have an idea of what you’re working with, taking 13+ shots at reeding a chanter is excessive (if you’re a seasoned reed maker).
Since each piece of cane is different, each working reed will sound different on some level. If it take that many attempts, try to make it to a tionol with a good reed making teacher, and try to refine what you’re doing. Run your method by the reed making teacher, especially the sticking points.
It really shouldn’t take more than a few tries at most to get something nice to play.
Sadly, I am not having much luck reeding my ‘C’ chanter. Get a working reed, but not very playable. Seem to be doing more fighting and struggling than playing! Sigh.
Arbo