Finger codes for instant transposing

When I am learning a new song, I write the finger codes (0 through 6, underscored for the second octave) between the lines - then I can play the piece on any of my whistles (C, D, Eb, F and G) by using the codes, and I often find the song sounds better in a different key. I’ve never seen this little trick mentioned anywhere and wonder if anyone else does it. Since I am only an advanced beginner, I wonder if I might be doing something wrong, oh dear.

[ This Message was edited by: Kendra on 2002-03-12 23:12 ]

There’s certainly nothing wrong with using a code that works for you. Go for it! And have fun.

I’m glad you brought this up. I play guitar as well and we use a code. It is six lines (strings) with numbers that indicate the fret to be played for each string. It’s called tableture or tab for short. I must admit I hardly ever use it, which is do to the fact that I play and learn by ear. I’m a bit lazy, and proud of it plus the ear works well for me.

Then again the whistle as simple as it is has gotten me to thinking I should dust off the old reading skills a bit, and this system that you mention has crossed my mind. If not to learn more tunes, to write down my own material so I can hand off the whistle part to someone else. Can’t play guitar, sing and whistle all at once…Oh man wouldn’t that be great!! A mutant one man whistle band?!!

Hi Kendra,

I’ve seen this code used occasionally, but what notation do you do for accidentals, e.g. C natural on the D whistle?

I used to use Guitar Tab almost exclusively for learning fingerstyle guitar, but once I have the piece learnt, the tablature goes away and I can focus on the sounds I’m making.

Ditto on the whistle, once the piece is learnt, I put visual references away (even keeping my eyes closed) so i focus on the sound. It shouldn’t matter then what key whistle you’re playing, you just play the same fingering. This would be akin to putting a capo on a guitar to transpose the key to something that suits my vocal range.

On 2002-03-13 04:59, Martin Milner wrote:
once the piece is learnt, I put visual references away (even keeping my eyes closed) so i focus on the sound.

I’m surprised at how many people play their instruments with their eyes closed! I keep mine open, and mind the fiddler (Eddie) because he tends to lean or look directly at you when he’s about to do something new/different/unusual. Sometimes its just rolling into a new tune in the set after only 2 reps, sometimes its a wonderful melodic variation.

It shouldn’t matter then what key whistle you’re playing, you just play the same fingering. This would be akin to putting a capo on a guitar to transpose the key to something that suits my vocal range.

I was wondering why Kendra does this tab in the first place. I was hoping for a neat and easy way to transpose D fingering to G or A (on the same whistle!) fingering easily.

Martin Milner wrote:

I’ve seen this code used occasionally, but what notation do you do for accidentals, e.g. C natural on the D whistle?

I just put the natural sign after the code, so C natural on a D would be written 0natural sign. And since the code is under the music line, I can see the notes above for reference, also.

I am not quite sure why it wouldn’t be easier to just memorize the tune on the D and then you don’t need to look at anything, staff-notation or fingerings, when you move to a different key whistle. It’s more fun playing from memory, too. :slight_smile:

Tyghress wrote:

I was wondering why Kendra does this tab in the first place. I was hoping for a neat and easy way to transpose D fingering to G or A (on the same whistle!) fingering easily.

The tab helps me memorize and makes it very easy to switch keys. When I read music, I tend to read by intervals and I find it hard to do with the whistle. I can play faster and with better timing using the codes.

I like to be able to switch keys on a song because I like to play other music (pop and rock, for instance), and that is seldom written in a key I have a whistle for - so for a piece written in E I just call E “6” and go from there, then play from the codes on a “compatible sounding” whistle. It’s kind of fun :slight_smile:

Oh, and another thing about this. Since I am now a “little old lady” I don’t memorize as well as I used to, and so I have written the tab for songs on 3x5 cards, which are a lot easier to carry around than books of music :slight_smile: I know how the song sounds, and if there is some ornamentation I really like and want to keep, I just put it in parenthesis after the note - but I am just learning ornamentation.

Kendra ~ I learned the numerical tablature from Glenn Schultz and have mentioned it before on the board. It seems much easier to me than ABC and it also helps me jot down a song that I hear and want to remember. For Cn on a D … I just put a / through the number and underline for notes in the upper register. Welcome to my world! Gm

_PS. I started out using a little notebook about the size of the index cards but that’s too neat n’ tidy for me…I’ve got scraps of paper and backs of envelopes here and there. When ever I come across one I stick it in a ziplock bag along with the other ones I’ve captured. :slight_smile:
Make a joyful noise!

[ This Message was edited by: Grannymouse on 2002-03-14 02:59 ]