Maybe I should have highlighted **..“Its how it is set up that counts”.**I have played some flat sets which have been quite a lot harder to blow and quite frankly when there is that much effort required then ,as Bill would say,there is something wrong… and again to quote Bill .."when they are handed a nicely reeded flat chanter " that is the key to it all.
Of course the flat set sounds sweeter so it will have an effect on the ear of the listener.
In many ways Pat,with tongue in cheek, is probably right as the concert does sound a bit like a trumpet in comparison to say a flute or in this case a flat set.I really think that if ye are having trouble with the concert set then there is something wrang and it needs to be sorted.They should not be a hard blow and it is not the way in Ireland..unless thats wot ye particularly want but I can’t see why ye would ![]()
Interestingingly enough just last night I woz speaking to a Gaelic singer who said that he couldna understand why some UPs sounded harsh to him (mine I presume
) and others were quite pleasing to him.He quoted the Ennis album which he liked.Whereas mine for instance sounded sharper..So I was able to inform him that a)He was playing on a C# set and therefore the sound was very different,and b)I was not nor ever will be Seamus Ennis..I then killed him ![]()
On reflection tho he was quite right they are different instruments and must have a different effect on the ear thus creating an instinctual reaction.I wonder if any research has been done on this.?
For my money the Flat is by far superior in every aspect and is the true Irish Union Pipe the Concert is its fun and funky teenage child with even a rebellious name… Uilleann.Wot ye play is a matter of choice and sometimes necessity (sessions etc)How ye play is a matter of practice practice and more practice there are no shortcuts.
Anyone else done the straw/diameter test yet or is it just my imagination?
Slán Go Foill
Uilliam
Its good to sound different, on whatever pitch you play.
Some B set players like a light set up (its easier to achieve on a flat set anyway) but there are some that I know who like stronger reeds relatively speaking and can create their own individual sound from that.
Some of the characteristic Ennis sound on C# is said to have come from his preference for a fairly robust (hard) chanter reed set-up, for instance.
Boyd
ps billh, sorry for squeezing the hell out of one of your reeds in the jacks in Cultra one September
pps Uilliam, you have mail
Jimmy O’Brien-Moran playing Sliabh Russell on D and B sets. Take your pick.
The advice about practicing is best. Concert sets are more prone to bad design, hard Ds and high Es that are a chore to sound properly for instance. That will certainly interfere with becoming musicial. Also all that volume can be a bit intimidating to listen to, even for the piper. Even the best flat chanter needs a good reed to do its thing though. Some of them are just bad in ways, possibly as a result of mucking about with the bore, Ennis’s famously bad Hard D for instance.
My C set is the set I play for my own pleasure as it sounds so much better and is easier to blow than my concert set. It also seems to have more tonal variation available than does the concert set.
I cannot make a reed for my Hillmann D 1/2 set that blows as easily as does my Gallagher C set for some strange reason.
I also have a Nick Whitmer D chanter that needs as strong a reed as does the Hillmann to sound right, so I don’t use the concert pitched sets much anymore as I am still fairly weak from my health problems.
Once you go flat, you will never go back. Flat pipes rule!
B set!
Amen!
It would be nice to spend more time working on my actual piping technique than trying to increase the stamina of my shoulder and its ability to hold the second octave and certain notes! I can play the notes just fine, skill is the easy part…stamina is the tough part and gets in the way of musicianship. Physical stamina/brute strength isn’t where good music comes from. Lately especially as I’m playing a new reed, which also may be a bit on the robust side…though it is a good reed. I wish I had the money for a B chanter!
Also, if nothing else I’d have more practice time due to the more “socially acceptable” qualities of a B chanter…
I think it’s also a matter of taste…the more time you spend with this stuff, the more sophisticated your palate becomes…thus the qualities of the flat set sound and technique are more appealing to those with some exposure. Many have their first encounter with the pipes hearing concert pitch sets…so for a while that’s the yardstick. If any of that makes sense…
I am afraid it makes no sense whatsoever to be talking about building up stamina or strength in the shoulder to hold notes…seriously guys and girls the reeds ye are playing are way too hard if that is the case and/ or the chanters are not as they should be.I can play awa for hours and think nothing of it and I didnae need to go to the Gym to play any of my reeds in.I suggest ye get your reeds frae Alan Burton aka reedshaman and then tell me that ye are using superhuman muscles to play a stick…I also suggest that ye check your sets for airtightness everywhere…Each type of pitch has its qualities they are just different.Horses for courses and all that.I am also a bit worried that ye are accepting as normal hard reeds /chanters as the norm and the accepted standard.If I substitute the word hard with "crap"would ye still be so forgiving of the maker? ![]()
Slán Agat
Uilliam
Never say never! You have your body, I am stuck with mine.
It does take a bit of work to play the pipes.
Try it at age 67 and with active Crohn’s disease and taking tons of prescription medicine, recovering from gall bladder surgery after 3 weeks in bed and I bet even you would break a sweat playing the easiest reeded set possible (my C set is the easiest playing flat set I have had the pleasure to try).
I certainly can’t play for hours, if I make 1/2 hour without a break, I consider myself doing fine.
Slàinte mhath! Or is that Sláinte mhath! I have seen the little divot going both ways…
Fancypiper..I am truly sorry to hear of your condition and I can appreciate your difficulties and fair play to ye for keeping it up but that is an extreme example and is not thankfully the norm for 99.9% of players.
Age is a factor I suppose, I am 60 this year and am deaf in both ears thanks to an explosion in my Fire Service days which brings its own problems..but that doesnae mean I have to put up wi Crap reeds or Crap chanters so I don’t see the argument.I can play Concert sets that don’t need a lot of pressure and some flat sets that do need pressure as well as those that don’t need so much pressure.Guess which ones I prefer ![]()
Wish ye well
Uilliam
Ta. At least the pipers I have heard in concert can go longer than can I (but I do see some sweat popping out, especially Jerry O’Sullivan)!
I am sorry to hear that. I have started hearing tinitus and I am suprised that I still have as good hearing as I do as I did construction work without ear protection when I was a teenager.
Uh.. Concert, because you can hear them?

I better get off the computer and get dressed to go down to Asheville, NC for a Remicade infusion. A day wasted and I am so tired after that that I can’t practice pipes for two days. Thank God, there are pennywhistles…
Uh.. Concert, because you can hear them?

…[/quote]
![]()
Slán Go Foill
Uilliam
Maybe this is the effect that I hanker after
.