I once took a community college continuing-ed class called “Old Time Fiddle for Beginners”. The teacher was a retired classical violinist who was very open about the fact that she was just playing around with “fiddling” and that she often missed playing real music in a symphony orchestra. I did not inquire about private lessons.
I know people who are fully invested in their arrogance, whatever it may be about, and see nothing wrong with demonstrating that; at least they know themselves…more or less. But somehow I get the impression from the above that your teacher was trying to be ethical with a “full disclosure”, and the arrogance slipped through unconsciously in a well-meaning conversational fashion. She might not have even been aware of it for what it was. And that, I think, is possibly worse if it’s true: not only for herself, but for the student who stands a very real risk at seeing him/herself in an unworthy light despite the best conscious intentions of the teacher.
But then, I’ve got very definite and strong opinions about teaching, and about what is good teaching and bad teaching.
Nope Nano, in the case of the classical “harpist” who screamed at me, I was not performing with her or knew her previously. She was no “harper” a term that many “harpists” find insulting. There are some classically harpist who think that the only real true technique is the accepted one for the classical instrument and all others are utter garbage be it Irish, Latin American etc. Apparently this entitles them to such crass behaviour. Happily the number of people who espouse this ugly attitude is shrinking.
The thing that upsets me the most is this; Wire harps and classical harps are totally different instruments. Why this is difficult for people to comprehend astonishes me. This harpist’s act of shaming me for using “poor form” is equal to a guitarist telling a violinist he’s got it all wrong “first of all that big hairy pick has got to go…and you should really find out what happened to your frets…”
After hearing this appalling woman go on about her classical training my reply to her was simple. “Here, since you are the expert, you play it then. If you can play this harp as well as I can, I’ll will give it to you”. The audience cheered. She left.
This obviously insane situation is what Irish wire harp players face. It has happened more than once to my mentor whose replies were not as charitable as mine. She equates it with “musical racism” and she has a point.
What some seem not to get: Classical harp technique evolved to address the musical needs of their instrument. The technique that harpers like Ann Heymann and I use is no less involved or demanding and addresses an entirely different set of needs and is as valid as any. This is the case with many other instruments and non-classical idioms.
I readily admit to my own long background in classical music having played harpsichord and organ for many years. Yet I always tell people I’m glad my box playing grandfather got a hold of me first. He taught me how to play tunes by ear and to really listen to music, rather than merely mechanically reproduce it. Perhaps I am a musician despite my training! There are many gifted classical musicians whom I hold in the highest regard as “real” musicians. Their mastery comes with great understanding. They have a deep respect for the abilities of others, even those whose genres they themselves do not understand.
Sure, it’s common for many people who are not born to the tradition to come to it via some kind of formal or art music training. It’s also one of those false binaries cherished by a certain breed of art music player. The idea of moving gracefully across boundaries makes their heads (and sometimes mouths) explode.
For the benefit of the harp-impaired like me … Is the situation different for non wire-strung Irish harpers?
Were you in the same class? 'Cause I think you’re dead on. She was obviously well-intentioned about teaching beginners how to play the fiddle, but at the same time gave the impression that she thought we were wasting our efforts on unworthy music. And I don’t think she knew she was doing that second bit.
Nah, I’m just an intuitive sort. It came to me in how you wrote about it; it gave me enough of an impression of a scenario, variants of which I’ve seen many times before, to hazard a guess.
There’s James Galway. But though I’ve heard it said that he remembers his roots in Ulster flute band music, I’ve never heard evidence of that. And his popular identification with “Irish” flute and whistle playing may have done as much harm as good.
Perhaps. However…
I’ve met James. He is a good guy and he cares deeply for Irish music. He has literally put his money where his mouth is…and done much to promote traditional music in Ireland at a time when it was about as welcome in many quarters as say an outbreak of Typhus. Long before it was trendy he befriended and assisted many traditional players over many years.
I agree it is hard to divine any traditionally influences in his flute playing. And while his whistle playing is hardly traditional in many senses, he did bring an instrument looked down on as a mere toy by some, took it to a wider audience and demanded some respect for it. That takes a certain amount of bravery in anybody’s book.
Slightly OT- Do either of you use phosphor bronze strings? I just did a complete restring of my hammered dulcimer using precut strings (couldn’t afford to buy wire in bulk right now) and the pb strings seemed more prone to breakage than the others.
Hey there SpringRobin,
I’ve been meaning to get back to you for some time. I’ll PM you about harps soon!
But you asked a good question about Phosphor bronze strings which got missed in the mix here. It is on topic as far as stringing material goes.
Bronze and brass have a lower tensile strength than steel. That does mean they are more prone to breakage than steel, so you have to tune more carefully down there. You will have to change them more frequently but it is worth it. The lower tensile strength and density gives brass and bronze a shorter speaking length and far better tone in the bass, both advantages in a dulcimer.
Moreover the instruments are usually designed for them. These copper-ally strings allows instrument builders an option in designing instruments that are more compact than they would be if all iron or steel strings were used. The sound of brass and bronze is much less bright than iron or steel and favours lower harmonics. For example it is one of the reasons that makes brass ideal throughout the range of a Gaelic harp played with fingernails, the brass strings yield a much nicer more colourful tone than steel.
The requirements of dulcimers are different. H-D strings are subjected to constant…hammering…so steel being far stronger is an ideal material for the most of the H-D’s range. But the tone of the low end benefits considerable from cooper-alloy strings and ph. bronze being stronger and harder than brass became the stringing of choice for most makers.
Precut string is usually less economical in the long run. If you are looking for good prices on music wire check out these guys. Best in the business IMHO, high quality material, good prices, very nice and very competent people. No minimums either. http://www.fortepiano.com/wire/index.htm
So…Treat bronze with some patience and it will serve you well!
CM
Oh, I don’t doubt that, nor that he has genuine respect and affection and support for the tradition. That’s the good. But in the context of someone of his stature and background who might have been able to set a living example of crossover but hasn’t, that’s the bad, or at least the disappointment. His popularizing tendency to promote himself as a “[u]Celtic Minstrel[/u]” while using trad music as material to exploit in a strictly classical style is problematic, IMO. It muddies the waters of audience perception, and it helps reinforce exactly the kind of elitist, classical condescension that can erupt, for example, in the misguided rant that interrupted your show. I think it’s hard to criticize the one without being at least circumspect about the other.
As for Sir James’ whistle playing, don’t get me started. But now we’re really OT. Sorry …
It would still be nice to have a ready crossover to point to, and I just can’t think of anyone offhand (my ignorance showing, no doubt). I actually know two great local examples - both superb ITM players, both full-time musicians with the San Diego Symphony. But they don’t have the recording history or name recognition that would impress the average punter.
In the part were Galway doesn’t live up to the crossover claims of his recording company…we are in total agreement.
As for Sir James’ whistle playing, don’t get me started. But now we’re really OT. Sorry …
Hey…Don’t be sorry. His whistle playing is…" a thing to itself" to put it diplomatically. People who can do crossover well are rare but it can be done.
For the benefit of the harp-impaired like me … Is the situation different for non wire-strung Irish harpers?
Good question. Yes, it is different.
But, nylon trad “Celtic” harp players who want to really play traditional music on their instrument face a different set of frustrations however.
In the last 40 years there has been a movement amongst some trad minded players to change their technique to better suit the needs of the music.
Their situation is complicated by the fact that classical harpists can play their instrument without any alteration of technique. As the norm for nylon lever harp technique was originally derived from classical technique in the first place, many classical musicians feel justified in treating the instrument as a smaller version of their own… while at the same time acting as it is an inferior version of the classical harp and playing music that more often than not has little to do with tradition music.
The result this in turn bolsters the view of some that the instrument doesn’t have a true place in the tradition, much to aggravation of those of us who know it can be done differently.
Again I stress, this is not the view of all classical harpists. But it is a source of friction for nylon harpers who want to do trad.
One of my personal pet peeves is someone saying that he or she is “moving up to pedal harp.” As a folk harper, I resent hearing my instrument referred to as though it were just a stepping stone on the way to playing pedal harp.
I recognize that a lot of classical harpists start on lever because a pedal harp is so darned expensive, but still, a little tact would be nice!
Wire harps are, indeed, completely different instruments. In fact, someone once asked me if I ever get confused between the two (picking up the wire harp, for example, and starting to play with high thumbs, stretched-down fingers, and fingerpads), but once you’re holding one, the differences are so apparent, there’s no confusing them. I have picked up my Harpsicle and unconsciously started to play it with the same technique as my Ravenna (the ‘sicle is much lighter tension, so it doesn’t take more than one or two “twangs” for me to realize who I’m playing), but the Bard really doesn’t feel at all like the other two, and one look at the strings should tell any harper that Ol’ Salzedo never played one of these beasties!
I’m curious Redwolf; did you get that string replaced yet? In reading through your comments, I suspect that the problem may be a ding or permanent dent in the string either right at the sound board or by the hitch pin.