Draft FAQ - 2nd Installment

Ok, I know its been a while, but here (finally) is the second installment of the Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ).

I’m ready to buy a set of pipes, where do I find a list of makers?

The board has been a bit quiet lately, so its about time we have a topic which is sure to create some debate. :sunglasses:

Here is the original topic re: FAQ
http://chiffboard.mati.ca/viewtopic.php?t=13961

Post your thoughts, comments and edits…after a few days, I’ll compile a new version based on the input received…no there is no committee or governing body. Only the free marketplace of ideas…so gentlemen and ladies…start your opinions!

When I believe we have gathered enough input, I’ll post a final version and send it to Dale to be appended to the existing FAQ.


4) I’m ready to buy a set of pipes, where do I find a list of makers?

Uilleann Pipes are hand made and generally a maker only builds to order..or on rare occasions, may have some extra time to build a few sets for stock. As a result, the wait time is usually 3 months for a practice set, 6 months or longer for a half set.

While everyone has a different opinion about who makes the best pipes, UPs generally fall into four categories:
a) Rubbish. Don’t waste your time or money.
b) Budget pipes. Low cost pipes which are intended for the beginning player.
c) Standard pipes. Well crafted pipes that don’t have a lot of decoration.
d) Fully mounted or deluxe. Same pipes as the standard pipes, but have more decoration, keys, etc.

As for which pipes fall into each of the above categories, you will need to form your own opinions. Here are some thoughts on what you might want to avoid…
http://chiffboard.mati.ca/viewtopic.php?t=4610
http://chiffboard.mati.ca/viewtopic.php?t=14262
http://chiffboard.mati.ca/viewtopic.php?t=14277

Regarding budget pipes, several makers offer a low cost way to get started. Some of the more popular options are the following:
http://www.daye1.com/pennychanter.html
http://www.thepiperscut.com/

Some thoughts on inexpensive pipes…
http://chiffboard.mati.ca/viewtopic.php?t=9539

Here are some pipemaker lists…
http://www.uilleannobsession.com/links_makers.html
http://www.pipers.ie/en/pipemakers.lasso
http://chiffboard.mati.ca/viewtopic.php?t=13864

Many of these makers produce pipes that range in price from budget through deluxe. It is best to find a maker who is as close to you as possible. This makes it much easier to resolve any problems that may develop with your pipes.

Know that most people do not want to say anything negative in a public forum, and the Chiff and Fipple has rules about how you go about reporting bad experiences (i.e. be specific). Therefore, if you post a question along the lines of “tell me about so-and-so” you may get a set of answers which are generally positive and won’t tell you everything you want (or need) to know.

Ask questions, search this site for past comments about a maker you are interested in, call them and talk about options, ask more questions…then form your own opinions about what you like/don’t like and make an informed decision.

Bump…

Ok, so either I have achieved perfection on the first try (hard to believe) :roll:

Or…its so bad no one wants to say anything. :confused:

Well?

-gary

Snoogie, no news is good news. Clearly we are all blown away by the thoroughness of your answers, and even-tempered handling of potentially contentious issues. Keep up the good work!

Have you heard from Dale how the FAQs will be presented? i.e. will they just appear with the announcements at the top of the list, or as a separate selection on the Forum Index?

Thx,

djm

Snoogie,

I think it’s vital to mention that anyone considering purchasing a set of pipes should go look at and listen to as many sets by as many different makers as possible (playing them would be obviously be a big plus too).

Once you’ve entered the realm of reputable makers, much of the choice comes down to personal taste (and there’s no accounting for taste).

No E

Thanks for the responses and the compliments.

djm, it will appear as it does now as an ‘announcement’ at the top of the forum.

Regards,
Gary