Well, after calling every Sam Ash music store in the metropolitan area, I finally found a YAMAHA (WX-5?) Wind Controller that I could try out. Drove 50 miles to Huntington, Long Island last Saturday, looking forward to putting down some neat sounds, etc.
The many young techies there were probably as revved up as I was–apparently, very few folks ever do anything more than say ‘what the heck is that thing?’ and they (and I) thought they were finally going to hear what it sounded like. After a few false starts (it did not have the requisite 6 AA bateries in it, for example, and they had none in the store[!], but finally found a power pack that worked intermittently), I did get some sounds out of it, but hit a real roadblock when the tune called for the second octave.
In short, it is counter-intuitive to operate for someone whose main instument is the Pennywhistle. Second octave (or third, fourth or fifth, from what I was led to believe[!], is attained by throwing one of several thumb switch/buttons on the back, etc. It was formidable, to say the least. No doubt, in the hands of someone with a saxophone background-- or, if a whistle player, the willingness & ability to ‘unprogram their hands’ --the transition might be easier.
I still have hopes of handling an AKAI, which looks simpler, but more or less assume I will not be acquiring an EWI. The net effect of this search for ‘my next instrument’ has been to re-dedicate myself to practicing and playing the pennywhistle. So, I guess it is an ill wind that blows no good. Speaking of not blowing good, did I mention that I found the Yamaha to be hard to play …
I appreciate the good feedback and leads from my fellow C & Fer’s, and was surprised to see that the thread had come back to life when I hit the Message Board this morning. I wish good luck to those of you with the skill to boldly go where this old dog probably won’t be going.
On the ‘up side’ of things, I think my number is about to come up on the Colin Goldie waiting list for an “A” whistle and another (F?–I forgot–it’s been a while), which will be more than ample consolation for venturing down the probable EWI dead end.
Tom Dowling