Well, after I fell in love with the Dixon sound and noticed that I could play the A with ease, I gambled and ordered a G, which I just got today. Even with my VERY small hands (that’s tiny fingers, small spread & limuted reach, the whole works), I can play the G with relative ease. There’s a bit of a stretch which I think will be soon gotten used to.
I never thought I’d be able to play anything below an A, so I’m excited. Is it possible that one day, some day, I can play a low D? Well, a girl can dream.
Anyway, if you want to go lower and have small hands, I recommend the Dixon G.
As for the difference between the two, they are basically the same wonderful whistles, just one is lower than the other. The lower one seems to be a little more tempormental but that’s probably just my inexperience playing the lower whistles!