I typically learn a new tune over the course of a few weeks. I finally get to the point where I feel like I’m doing a competent job and where I think I have the tune committed to memory. But, then if I don’t play that tune for a while (maybe a few days or a week) I can’t remember much of it and I get very frustrated 
I guess my question is, “At what point can you say that you truly have a tune committed to memory?”
Any other suggestions for committing tunes to memory would be appreciated. Thanks all.
Gary
(who finally created his very own on-topic thread)
[Edited to improve clarity]
[ This Message was edited by: garycrosby on 2002-08-24 11:42 ]
I’ve heard it said two ways. In one previous thread from a long time ago a poster said when he can be playing the tune, see that the barmaid is holding up a beer to ask him if he wants it, and he can wink at her to say yes he does, and never lose a beat of the tune, then at that point he truly knows it.
Another guy who plays in the local session here told me that he never thinks of what his fingers are doing. If he does, he loses it completely. So I guess if you can play a tune without thinking at all, you truly know it.
It seems to me there are many different levels of “knowing” a tune. There’s knowing how to play along if someone else starts it, and knowing how to start it yourself. There’s knowing it well enough to handle it at full speed in a session with other people, and knowing it well enough to start it after another tune in a set. And there’s knowing the many different things that can be done to the tune, the little twists and turns it can take without losing its thread. (Not that you ever can know all of those.)
There’s many methods to ‘know’ a tune. Most basic I think, is by continuous listening (not playing). If it’s stuck in your head, preferably when you’re younger (not necesarily teen and lower) it IS stuck…
Continous playing don’t really work for the masses in long term, most (80%?) lose the tune without practice. It takes time to find out what fits you, or to find that one method you can do and others can’t.
I find that if I close my eyes and play (whatever little I know to), the fingers just, just go on. Even when my mind is halfway to sleep…odd huh? Just lose yourself, and you won’t lose the tune. Again, odd.
I find that if I learn a new tune, say, playing it over all day, and having it memorized, by the next day, I’ll probably have to look at printed notes to remember how to start it. If I work at it a bit every day, this trend fades gradually. The thing is, it seems sleep or time allows things to settle in and become permanent. Once it’s in, it’s really there. I may have really learned a tune years ago and then totally forgot about it. Then, I hear it, think, hmmm, that sounds familiar, and realize my fingers remember it better than my auditory memory. Sometimes, I know a version of a tune I play is a bit different than what I’m used to hearing on recordings I listen to these days. I listened to a recording recently that I hadn’t in years and realized that’s where I got my version of the tune. (I thought I had cleverly devised the phrasing or ornamentation myself.) This is a good lesson to college students. Don’t study until the night before an exam, then cram. You may do well on the exam, but you’ll forget everything in another day or so. Study ahead of time and then casually review before the test- much easier and less stressful (and more reliable). And if the material is worth remembering for the long haul…
And for performance situations, I’ve learned the hard way: don’t do it until you know you know it. The distractions of the situation can throw you off if you’re not certain of what you’re doing. Especially if another band member makes a mistake.
Tony
I am an “advanced beginner”, I know about 25 tunes by heart. After a hard work of learning the first 15 tunes, now I learn much faster, I learn just few “points” of tune, other tones go automaticaly. Interestingly, I just marked the first tone of every melody to my list of tune names, and it helped dramatically! After playing the frst tone, other tones go automaticaly (to my surprise).
There is one interesting point: if I can sing the melody, I know how to play it automaticaly (after some learning of important “points” of melody). If I forget some melody (i.e. I am not able to sing it), I am not able to play it. So it seems that in fact I am able to (unconsciously) assign fingering to tones I sing imaginarily in my mind.
Sorry for my “czenglish”
) .