Difference between a reel and a hornpipe?

How can you tell the difference between a reel and a hornpipe?

To my newbie ears, a reel (in general) seems like a fast, four-beat driving rhythm where most notes are the same length.

A hornpipe (in general) seems like a slower four-beat tune, with a swing-style rhythm (for lack of a better term), and more melodic, less “driving”.

However, I’ve heard a few tunes classified as reels that seem like they could pass for hornpipes, and maybe vice versa.

How can you tell the difference? Are there any tell-tale indicators?

Thanks,
Jason

This question comes up a lot here and there. I’m tempted to answer, you’re on the right track, just keep on listening, but that’s probably not what you want to hear.

There was some discussion of the amount of swing in hornpipes and reels here a while ago: http://chiffboard.mati.ca/viewtopic.php?t=6509

There are some typical melodic features of hornpipes, the most obvious being the three quarter-notes that end the tune sections, often in the pattern 1 - 3 - 1 (or some rhythmic variation of this pattern). Hornpipes often have passages of 2 or 4 or more groups of triplets in them. More modern hornpipes of the kind that many flashy fiddlers are enamoured of go in for quite a bit of chromaticism, plus lots of leaping around. Here’s a good example but played by a whistler: http://www.rogermillington.com/tunetoc/acrobat_skelton.html

The question of whether notes are of the same length in reels is an interesting one and may depend on the instrument being played. In the hands of most good players, the notes will have some unevenness, either of length or, more subtly, of weight.

Anyway, keep on listening!

Steve

To clarify, by “notes are the same length”, I didn’t really mean literally. There seems to be a bit of swing in there too, just faster than a hornpipe. What I really meant was that the repetition of the note pattern seems to be more of a rhythmic driving force in a reel, rather than the “sing-song” melody that seems to be more predominant in a hornpipe.

Thanks for the info, I’ll keep listening and reading. :slight_smile:

Jason

I knew there was something else about this somewhere on here and I have just found it. It starts off innocuously talking about swing in reels, and quickly gets off topic and very entertaining. This thread gave the impetus for this here forum, not to mention the transcriptions and commentaries that I referred you to above.

Have fun reading: http://chiffboard.mati.ca/viewtopic.php?t=5105.