Demented Arby's Commercial?

So what does everyone think of the Arby’s Commerical with the Monkeys doing Irish line dancing?

Does anyone think it’s racist or is just outright hillarious.

In case you missed it, here’s an extended version on youtube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=44Y-_JAjAwE

Not sure how it could be interpreted as racist unless some paranoid person thinks it implies that the Irish are akin to chimpanzees which I doubt anyone would find the commercial to mean. I, on the other hand, found the commercial more freaky and bizarre than anything else, the legs don’t seem to mesh up with the rest of the bodies!

How can it be racist when those are apes, just like us, not monkees? Now, if you wanted to address the question about whether or not apes have rhythm, that would be another topic altogether.

THAT WOULD BE ANOTHER TOPIC.

Thx, everyone. :smiley:

djm

Is it racist to make fun of Riverdance?

Or “Lard” of the Dance?

djm

I haven’t been able to work at RB’s since working there around 15 years ago, but those sandwiches actually look good. Must be time to raid the fridge…

Tom

But do they have souls? :smiley:

T

well, all I can say is Tom and I were rolling on the floor we were laughing so hard when we saw this for the first time last night!
(or it could have been the wine…)

:laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

It’s been done. :wink:

djm

In the middle of the 19th century English newspaper cartoons often depicted the Irish as chimpanzees in their attempt to portray the country as being made up of savages.

I don’t think that was the intention here. I found the river-dancing chimpanzees to be amusing in the same vein as the old Mac dancing baby.

I have not made a conscious effort to dislike any commercials where animals are made to act like people, especially those where computers make them 'talk, but that hasn’t stopped me from having an extreme bias toward them nonetheless.

I also hate commercials/movies/shows where they make old people do things like cartwheels and breakdancing after sipping a Pepsi or something.

I agree with alurker. I came across a reference to the Irish as monkeys in something from 19th c. England I read—can’t remember what it was. I believe the person really thought the Irish were monkeys—the person did not think they were human beings.

I have not come across racial slurs in my lifetime in the US, or in American literature I’ve read that refered to the Irish as monkeys or simian beings—just my experience. The slurs against the Irish I’ve come across have taken other forms.

I think it is reasonable to wonder if the video is racist because of the history of refering to the Irish as being some sort of simian beings in Britain in the 19th c. (I really don’t know much about it, maybe other centuries too), but since the video is, presumably, for an American audience I don’t think it is. I don’t think many Americans are familiar at all with how the Irish were refered to in England in the 19th c. I think it is just capitalizing on the popularity of that Riverdance stuff.

It didn’t really tickle my funny bone, but the Youtube video wasn’t very clear. I don’t know, you might just have to be in the mood.

I guess I took it as saying that even the chimps want to get in on the River Dance rollercoaster… I didn’t think it was commenting on the Irish, but on the American propensity for bastardizing… er… I mean… adopting anything that seems cool.

hmmm… so… is ‘Bush’ an Irish name?

Wait… no… I didn’t say that… not on this board… nope. :smiley:

This particular link is to a remix and that’s why the music is not in sync with the steps and kicks. It’s not the original music. Kinda fuzzy too. Wonder why they bothered since the original is much better.

My daughter has been step dancing for years, so, as you can imagine, I have been indirectly involved for years too. We have yet to find any dancer, young or old, that did not find this ad at least a little funny.

As for racism, I can’t imagine there was any malicious intent. I just don’t understand this hypersensitivity when it come to race. I have a multicultural, multiracial background and I grew up in the south when racism was commonplace. There’s plenty of racism in the world without looking for it.

Lurker, you beat me to the punch, I was also going to post that exact cartoon.

ok, realizing this is a multi-country board…

There have been a LOT of commercials lately that have chimps in them. There’s a whole series for some resume’ placement company (see, they worked so well I don’t remember what they were advertising), and one for a computer or office supply company, etc.
There’s also been a lot of jokes about Riverdance type dancing (as opposed to the REAL Irish step dancing). Including Chad Johnson doing a dance in the end-zone after a touchdown a couple of years ago (American Football).

I’m sure the people that made this commercial had NO intention or any idea of any racial overtones.

So - what do people think of any commercial, etc. that makes fun of “hillbillies”?

I think minstrel shows evolved into hillbilly shows.

The best ads ever made using chimpanzees were the [u]Trunk Monkey[/u] commercials.

Well, now I have learned that the term “hillbilly” is offensive to people living in the mountains in the east and that they would greatly prefer that the term and the stereotype not be used, I would think the commercial was offensive and I would think it was very stupid to be making fun of people and offending them when you are apparently trying to get customers.