challenging tunes

i’m finding the “lads of laois” as played by jack coen challenging, esp. the ‘b’ part. great tune.

playing the ‘a’ rolls cleanly and at a decent clip in “maids of mt. ciso” is hard for me. playing ‘e’ rolls in “fermoy lasses” and not running out of breath is another challenge.

love the low matt malloy “drowsy” as someone mentioned. i play in on my ‘c’ flute, very nice setting. playing the ‘b’ part of “last night’s fun” in the style of mike rafferty is fun but difficult for me, need to go back to it.

but as one wise person put it earlier, all tunes are hard to play well, even the “simple” ones.

“Faerie’s Aire and Death Waltz”

(Sorry, couldn’t find the ABC notation)

I really like to [try to] play Ed Reavy tunes. They’re written for fiddle and they wander all over the place. They’re a real challenge for me. There’s a fiddler at my session who knows a bunch of Reavy tunes and he puts up with me trying to stumble through a few of them with him.

Cheers,

Kirk

“i’m finding the “lads of laois” as played by jack coen challenging, esp. the ‘b’ part. great tune.”

This is actually the Humours of Lissadel–the labeling got screwed up.

Great tune.

I can accept on its own the simple statement that D# notation is supposedly harder to read than Eb (I can read neither), but there is something about the rest of the above that hits me as being beside the point for the following reason:

If I’m playing an otherwise D tune on an Eb flute I can still read it in D, for Eb fingerings on Eb flute are the same as D fingerings on D flute. Conversely, if I had the literacy to read easily in Eb or D#, instead of needing an Eb flute I should still be able to play that tune in D on a D flute using that notation as well and for the same reasons. In other words, let’s say I have a D tune to play, but someone hands me an Eb flute unbeknownst to me. What difference does the notation make, then? Same as if I’m going by Eb or D# notation but I get handed a D flute under the same circumstances; if all of a sudden I’m told, “Ha. You were just playing a different-pitched instrument,” I know I wouldn’t crash and burn over it. I’d probably say, “Whatever,” and keep playing.

So unless you are positing that I would be playing with an ensemble in which at least one member absolutely requires the properly corresponding notation without which s/he cannot function, what am I missing, here? In the ITM world - and these are all ITM tunes being discussed (imagine that) - print is essentially unessential, however you write the tune. The tune itself is what is difficult, or not, and this depends all the more on what key you play it in on your instrument as well. But I’m all about the practicalities, that way. Would I play The Foxhunters in A? I think not. That’s for the fiddlers, to my liking.

There’s a reel that I learned to play in G Mixolaneous (indeed that is the only key I have ever heard it played in), and wanting to double-check on some things but having mislaid my go-to CD for it, I finally found a printed version but this version happened to be in E Mixolaneous. Aside from the possibility that that may have been the actual key the tune was originally written in (Paddy Fahey; what do you think the odds are?), the key mattered nothing to me so long as I could read it. Key be damned: the tune is the tune is the tune. That’s it. If I play Mother’s Delight in Em instead of the more customary Dm, it’s still Mother’s Delight, and no longer near as difficult on flute on top of it.

There’s a reel that I learned to play in G Mixolaneous (indeed that is the only key I have ever heard it played in), and wanting to double-check on some things but having mislaid my go-to CD for it, I finally found a printed version but this version happened to be in E Mixolaneous. Aside from the possibility that that may have been the actual key the tune was originally written in (Paddy Fahey; what do you think the odds are?), the key mattered nothing to me so long as I could read it. Key be damned: the tune is the tune is the tune. That’s it. If I play Mother’s Delight in Em instead of the more customary Dm, it’s still Mother’s Delight, and no longer near as difficult on flute on top of it.

Your point fails as soon as you’ll want to play the tune with other musicians, usually fiddlers…

Unless you play it on a C flute. I would do both learn it in Em fingerings and using keys on a D flute for the for the buzz of it. Key is irrelevant. It’s time fiddle players started coming towards us anyway. I have flutes in many keys and like to get string players to use their capos (some old banjos sound better with lighter strings and capoed up to f say) and fiddle players to tune down. For too long its been all about the fiddlers and boxers. Martin Hayes would do both I should think sometimes he tunes down sometimes he plays within the key signature on a normally tuned instrument. Damn the fiddlers is how I used to feel until I discovered the joys of flutes i lower keys and with lovely keywork.

Not necessarily. I quite often come across someone starting a tune in a key which is different from the one more commonly used. In my experience, people just play it in the new key. Not a problem. It depends on whether the musicians play tunes, or have just simply memorised the fingering.

I think it makes a huge difference how familiar one is with one’s instrument. For instance, on flute, which is a relatively new instrument for me, I can’t transpose too well. On fiddle, which I’ve been playing since I was a nipper, I don’t even think of it as transposing - I just play the tunes. If someone starts one up in a less than usual key, I’ll notice, in a kind of ‘Oh, that’s interesting’ kind of way … but then just play the tune.

This has made me curious - I wonder if that is my relative familiarity with the different isntruments, or whether it’s actually easier to do that on fiddle than on flute. :confused:

I find it much easier to play in any key on a banjo or mandolin or guitar than flute. For instance I never play in Eb on a flute without changing flutes but don’t use a capo on a banjo.

Whilst proficiency doubtless affects one’s facility at such transpositions on any given instrument, I think from impressions I have of how fiddles work that, although there are easier and harder keys to play on them, once a player is practised in all the key-scales the physical differences are in general less/less of an obstacle than on a wind instrument. Fiddles and other multi-stringed instruments have a broader tonal baseline than necessarily mono-linear winds, which makes more tonalities more accessible closer to home, as it were, as well as offering more variable approaches to them and relationships between them.

Well, on the fiddle you just move your fingers and you’ll find a string anyway, no big deal, on the flute you will more likely find a key instead of a hole, which changes everything. Trad flute players rarely use the keys, we’re usually not used to them. I’m sure Niall Keegan could change a tune on the fly to ANY key.
Changing key can change the feel or mood of a tune. I usually don’t like to change the mood of a tune. And us flute players should learn to use those fckn keys. We have it, why don’t we use them? We’re limiting the instrument…

On the Boehm woodwinds (sax & flute) I never cared what key anyone chose to play in. 'course as I was just filling holes (not playing the melody or bass parts) I didn’t much care if I knew the tune/song either.

Flute is more of a frill than a fill maybe.

Simple system is a bit more difficult to pull off.

Always the anarchist! :poke:

jes’ another rebel without a clue :wink:


so has it changed much in the last 35 years?

Not at all. Your observation is sidestepping. What I say still stands. The tune is the tune is the tune.

But let’s go with the sidestep. You also assume I’ll want to play certain tunes with others, “usually fiddlers”. That is also not true. I have a number of tunes that I resolutely play in “the wrong key” and I’m not concerned in the slightest that I can’t play them at your usual session. Those tunes I think of as “mine”; they are for the day when I’m doing solo melody (in fact I happen to be working on exactly such a wee project and I’m relishing the prospect of presenting those tunes in nonstandard formats), and I’m totally fine with that. Now, IF I want to play with others or others want to play with me, then yes, of course concordance in some form is necessary, but that’s a different issue and not at all what I was talking about above.

I may normally conform to session standards, but I’ll be damned if I’m going to tug my forelock and hand primacy over lock, stock, and barrel to the fiddlers just because someone bestowed upon them an iconic status. As far as I’m concerned fiddlers can also work with me on my terms just as well as I can theirs. Not that that’s likely to happen, of course. :smiling_imp:

Of course, for solo playing or if you have a group, you can do what you prefer.
But at least to me, the mood of a tune can sound very different if you play it at a different pitch. Better or worse I can’t say, but different. And the way you play the tune will also be different whatever instrument you’re playing, because different tones will be on a different part of the instrument, and allowing diffrent ornamentations. This is particularly true on the flute.

“Godlike” is, I think you’ll find, the word you were looking for.

:laughing:

All of it absolutely true, Lorenzo. It’s not just that they may merely fit better on flute in another key; the only reason I hang on to those tunes is because I like the way they sound when “repurposed”, if we could call it that. You mentioned making more use of our flutes’ keys if we have them, and I agree that that would be great practice. I should do more of that; but out of what I have done, my favoritest way ever to play Slieve Russell has come to be low, in the key of Dm. So dusky and moody-sounding. Besides, strictly on the philistine side, I paid enough for those lower C#/Cnat keys, so I’m gonna find any excuse to use 'em if it sounds good, and if I can make it sound good.

If there’s to be a time I should ever abase myself to someone because he has a fiddle in his lap, it will be in all irony, and that irony will be unmistakeable. Don’t get me wrong; I loves me some good fiddle. To pieces, in fact. :slight_smile:

That cuts me out then. I only play woodeny ones.