OK, so the Generation Bb I got sounds great. Only had to remove some rough plastic pieces. But then while I was looking at the diameter of the whistle it occured to me that the tube will fit into my Sweetheart Pro D upper segment. Being naturally curious I tried the tube and headjoint together by inserting the lower part of the tube, and what do you know…it really does fit. All I need to do now is remove the fipple, which seems to be soundly gluded in place, and I can try this new configuration. Any tips on removing a fipple?
Thanks
i just keep on yankin, and it will pop right off. but other people soak it in hot water. i just twist and pull, twist and pull.
It’s called “making whistle tea”. Hot water from the tap in a cup (not boiling!) and just give it a moment or two. The mouthpiece will pop right off. It’s an old trick for making those whistles tunable.
But Scott, seriously, you’re about to stuff a chunk of perforated water pipe into one of the finest hand-crafted wood whistles on the planet. Are you really sure you want to do this experiment? Please don’t go there. The synthetic cork of the Sweet can be replaced at a nominal charge, but really, there’s no good reason to go on with that idea. The head joint of the Sweet is considerably different than that designed for the Generation. Even though by coincedenence the diameters are a rough match, no good will come of it and you’ll risk scoring the wood with the brass.
Be careful you don’t make your fipples sore.
–James
Much as I admire your imagination, I don’t think you will like the result. The extra length of the head will make it hopelessly out of tune.
Yep, it sucked…but it does make some strange notes. Ya never know if you don’t give it a try. The extra length seems to be less of a problem than the air that can be pushed through. Big tube wants more air, small fipple wants to jump octave.
Remind me not to read this forum while drinking anything. I read this last night and I do believe that for the first time in my life I snarfed Guinness.
Plasma Cutter
C4
Delta Force Sniper Practice
Send it to OCC (Just don’t let Mikey work on it)
Attach it to a Space Shuttle solid rocket booster
Hire a Samurai
Make friends with an Octopus
Poke a lion with your whistle, or use it to tease a Gorrilla
If you need more suggestions, let me know.
Loren
Generation fipples are easy to remove a little hot water and off it comes but I have an older Oak, 10 years or so, that will not budge.
OK, so the Generation Bb I got sounds great. Only had to remove some rough plastic pieces. But then while I was looking at the diameter of the whistle it occured to me that the tube will fit into my Sweetheart Pro D upper segment. Being naturally curious I tried the tube and headjoint together by inserting the lower part of the tube, and what do you know…it really does fit. All I need to do now is remove the fipple, which seems to be soundly gluded in place, and I can try this new configuration. Any tips on removing a fipple?
All the “right” answers to your question have already been offered but your description of the Gen/Sweetheart fit reminded me of the scariest method I have ever seen used to make a Gen type whistle tunable. I am sure others here have witnessed this ritual too. I observed this at a workshop moderated by a well loved whistle player. The method used to loosen the heads involved sliding the gen type tube into the finger tube of an O’Riordan and then using the O’Riordan as a slide-hammer to persuade the plastic head off the metal tube. Yikes! In the end it worked with no apparent damage to anyone’s whistles.
Feadoggie
All very tried and true methods, Loren? 
Lucky you didn’t read the “hand lotion/soft and supple” thread, you might well have drowned. Drinking while reading C&F is right up thee with driving while whistling: we all do it but the list of those forcibly cured grows longer every day.