Avery Tweaked LBW

Here is a link to another review of a tweaked LBW. The whistle I have tried is not the same whistle. The one I had is #2.

http://chiffboard.mati.ca/viewtopic.php?t=34358&sid=72dc6ecb855708ed7da6a7a8268be4ee

Right away I want to let you know that this is the first formal review I have done. Although I have tried to be as impartial as possible, reviews do tend to be subjective to the likes and dislikes of the person reviewing. Please excuse any errors. Please let me know and allow me to correct them if found. I have tried to use a format similar to Wanderer’s since it seems to get the information across in a very organized manner. I also have had the assistance of Doc Jones with this review. I used him as my expert advisor/player.

Here is a picture of three LBW’s all together:

The first thing you may notice is the difference in total length. Not only is the tweaked LBW a lot longer than the two that are not tweaked (most likely do to the tweaking process), the two stock ones are different lengths as well!!! Quality control at its “best?”

Next is a pic of the head area of the whistles:

This emphasizes the difference in total length and also shows off Avery’s added label. There is also a difference in the stock labels that I assume indicated different manufactuing eras.

An overall view of the tone holes:

A closer view of the upper holes:

and the lower holes:

The holes look quite worked and appear to be rough. They are, however, not rough to the touch during play. Only the upper hole feels a bit rough when specifically rubbed with a finger tip. I think the exposed aluminum was the first thing I noticed when taking the whistle out of the package, especially when compared to the stock whistles on hand. A bit of touchup paint or permanent marker would go a long ways at improving the overall appearance.

Here is the windway entrance:

You can see that some material has been added to the floor of the windway. I believe this is to reduce the size of the hole. This would reduce the air requirement and increase the backpressure. I found both of these conditions to be true.

Now the windway exit:

If you look really closely you can see some material has been added in the space under the exit of the windway. It appears to be some sort of foam. This is apparently similar to the blue tack mod that has been discussed on this forum in the past. It appears to be securely attached and I did not have any difficulty with it coming loose.

And finally a close up of the blade area:

The blade of the tweaked whistle (left) seems to have been modified in some way. I think it has been dulled as there are some fine abrasion marks on and near this area. I had to look really closely to see them though.

Now, what does all of this add up to?

Sound of the whistle:
The whistle is noticably breathier than the stock whistles.

Tuning:
When I played the whistle so that the bell note was in tune and attempted to keep my breath volume and pressure constant up through the scale it liked to stay a bit on the flat side for half the notes and in tune for the rest. I also tried doing this with the stock whistles. The longer of the two seemed to be balanced around being in tune with a few notes being in tune, a couple above and a couple below. The shorter of the two had a similar response as the tweaked whislte, but being on the sharp side of things.

When I tried the same idea starting at B (playing in tune and keeping breath and pressure constant as possible) and coming down the scale, by the time I got to F# it was jumping to the second octive. The stock whistle, while I could tell they wanted to did not do this.

I realize this may be a silly thing to try, but I did and wanted to report the results. All notes were well within range of being blown into tune on all three whistles though. I also think that being on the flat side (for a constant breath) is an advantage of sorts because it is easier to give a little more breath support to bring it in tune than it is to attempt giving less. This works as long as the break to the second octive is not so sensitive.

Cnat:
Using a tuner I attempted to find the optimal fingering for Cnat for each whistle. What I found was that the tweaked whistle was most in tune with a OXXXXO fingering but it was not as strong sounding note as the regular scale notes. The stock whistles seemed to be most in tune with OXXXOX. This fingering produced a note that was closer in quality to the other notes.

But how does it play?
I had my stand-in expert (Doc Jones) play it some about a week ago. He indicated that the tweaked whistle was a bit more stable during play than the untweaked whistles. He noticed the breathiness right off and that put him off. It was too breathy for his (and our) liking. We played the whistles again tonight and at first he had some difficulty with it as it wanted to break into the second octive on him. He was able to get a handle on it and played a couple of tunes with it as well as the stock whistles.

Overall we liked the longer of the two stock whistles better. It was the excessive (to us) breath sound that was the main deciding factor. The longer stock whistle was close enough in tune to be servicable and just sounded better to our ears. Using a “standard” OXXOOOO Cnat was not terribly noticable during play on the stock whistle, but was fairly noticable on the tweaked one.

The shorter of the two stock whistles was playable but requires a bit of attention and was always trying to play sharp with “normal” playing. This whistle would probably be a candidate for a tweak such as this if one really wanted to have it be a better player.

First, I would like to thank Steve and Doc for this review. Now to address some things. The difference in length is probably due to having to pull the head a bit further out to get the bell note in tune. Yes the aluminum showing is from working on the holes to improve tuning, I have tried to get an equal temperment tuning. I have also not tried to get the whsitle in tune at the same pressure for each note but rather the usual amount of air I would use for that note that should explain why some notes were off using the same amount of pressure. The two untweaked LBWs are the older style you can tell by the gold verses yellow labels I am pretty sure this was done a couple years ago. Personally I like the look of the silver color on black it shows a contrast which I think looks pretty neat, maybe I would hear some more feed back from others on this it would be no problem to make that part black. I have used the guitar pick tweak which is what is in the windway and mainly done to increase back pressure, but it does add to the breathiness of the sound. I have used foam instead of blue tac as it adds a bit more complexity to the sound. That is pretty much what I would say about it.

I received the instrument yesterday. I will be posting my comments in a day or two. <>>

Great. I have noticed that as I tweak more and more I keep getting better.

Sorry to drag up an old thread, but I just got the touring whistle
mentioned in this review, and I thought it would be better to just
add my comments here than start a new thread. In the interest of
fairness: I have never played an UNtweaked LBW before, so I can’t
really compare the pre-tweaked whistle to the tweaked one.

Like Steve and Doc Jones, I also noticed the breathiness right off. It’s
entirely too breathy for my tastes, especially in the upper octave. But,
because of this, ornaments (especially cuts) seem to stand out in
sharp relief, which is pretty cool. I wonder if a compromise could be
struck. Could the guitar pick be placed on the ceiling of the windway
instead of the floor? It seems like this would achieve the same
backpressure increase without the breathiness, but I’m just guessing.

I also noticed that the 0XXX0X Cnat is sharp. After I came back and
read this review, I tried 0XXXX0, which is certainly more in tune but
hard to maintain. I think I would have to half-hole Cnat if I was
holding it for any length of time.

This whistle has a large range for tuning, at least in the flat direction.
And Avery has sanded the tube so that the mouthpiece moves very
easily. The most useful tweak on my Freeman SweeTone is where
Jerry filed down the fipple-end of the tube so that there was more
room to push the mouthpiece in (make the whistle sharper). I don’t
know if that’s necessary with the LBW since you had to sharpen
many of the notes anyway, but it might be a useful consideration…

Like I said, I haven’t seen an LBW before, but I really like the tube
on this thing. It feels light but strong, and the black paint gives it a
grip similar to my brass Feadog, without the feeling of brushed
metal. And, I still say the contrasting aluminum around the holes
looks cool. Oh well.

At any rate, I think Avery has chosen a good whistle to tweak. If the
breathiness could be reduced by half and the 0XXX0X Cnat brought
into tune, I think this would be a whistle of character and style.

I can’t see the pictures. :frowning:

You could see them back in November when they were originally
posted. They must have hit their “view by” date. You should’ve
been there. They were magnificent!

Putting the pick on top, I had never thought of that. I just got a new pack of them so I will be sure to try that.

I just got the whistle today. I like the sound. Breathiness is actually a plus with me. It’s an improvement on that strident Walton sound. I think the silver on black could be a striking look, but only if you even out the rough look of the holes.

I don’t see the guitar pick. Where’s the pick!? I hope it hasn’t been lost somewhere along the way. I’m also not seeing the blue foam.

Overall, yes, it improves the sound and backpressure. Avery, you’re on the right track.

Okay, I’ve got it. The foam is black. It’s still there. And is that blue thing the guitar pick? It’s just inside the tip of the mouthpiece. That’s a nice idea. I somehow misunderstood the guitar pick tweak. All this time I thought you would use it to dull the blade, like Jerry uses a plastic strip to tweak the Mellow Dog. Not a bad whistle, Avery. Again, to sell people on the aluminum around the soundholes, you’ll probably have to make them more even and attractive. Do that and I’d agree it’s a sharp idea.

There are several uses for a guitar pick. On my Freeman Feadog, a
pick is used to change the blade angle, on my Freeman SweeTone,
a pick (or some other clear plastic) is glued inside the windway to
change the backpressure (I guess).

This is a very interesting thread.

I use a lot of different materials, but I don’t use guitar picks at all.

Best wishes,
Jerry

Totally OT, but fun nonetheless, Jerry’s post reminded me of what my dad used to say about picks.

When our “friends” proved themselves unworthy:

You can pick your friends,
and you can pick your nose.
But you can’t wipe your friends under the table.

When he wanted to mess with our heads:

You can pick your friends,
you can pick your nose,
and you can pick a banjo.
But you can’t pick your friend’s nose with a banjo.

Hmmmm… A banjo can be Trad, so maybe it’s not an OT post after all.