Hmm, I thought I was just copying the fingerings in the original, unless I’m reading them wrong (am I?). Heck, if Bartok says I have a zeroth finger, who am I to object?
I reckon Bartok in ABC is like teaching a dog to dance the Tango. As Johnson says, it’s not done well, but you are surprised to find it done at all. Still, for a system that started with scribbling tunes on napkins, it’s fairly capable as long as you can live with the (mostly reasonable) defaults. It’s when you want finer control over placements that things get dicey. You can always manually edit the PostScript output (which I’ve done) or manipulate it with something like Perl or Python (which I’ve done), but that’s pretty extreme and geeky.
For my limited purposes nowadays - mostly IrTrad tune transcription and an occasional multipart - ABC is great. If I wanted fancier output, I’d import the ABC into e.g. Sibelius or Finale and gussy it up there.
I asked the question about the Bartok on the abc list. Here’s a solution that places the key signature correctly
X:1
T:Hands Crosing
M:3/4
L:1/8
Q:“Lento,” 72
V:1 clef=treble
V:2 clef=treble
K:none
%%score {1 | 2}
[V:1] [K:none _e] !mf! (CD E3 F | ED C3 B, |
[V:2] [K:none ^F ^G] !p! “_sempre legato” c3 B cB | c3 B AB |
Apparently you can place the key signature items by upper and lower case letters, something I thought might be true but did not know and could not find in the little digging I did.
Sure, it certainly should. The chord patterns and cadences inferred by the software analyzing a given melody could (and likely would) be quite different depending on the key/mode assigned.*
Bit IIRC, the only time I played with one of those auto-chord things, the result sounded like a drunken pianist anyway.
Every ITM accompanist has probably had this experience: You hear an unfamiliar tune for the first time, and after the first repetition you craft and play a lovely chord progression. Only to be told afterwards that the tune is actually in a completely different mode or key from what you were playing (and, obviously, hearing).
An honest approach, to be sure. But frankly, I doubt most casual ITM users of ABC are even aware that you can assign key sigs like that. So it could be confusing. Very useful though for notating Balkan modes, maqams, etc.
For sure. But, as something that just grew out of your comments re. key signatures, it’s interesting!
As Johnson says, it’s not done well, but you are surprised to find it done at all.
Think you edited your post to add that bit? But, again, you started it with that isomorphism stuff and its ability to do more than it’s usually asked!
Still, for a system that started with scribbling tunes on napkins, it’s fairly capable as long as you can live with the (mostly reasonable) defaults.
Happily agreed.
It’s when you want finer control over placements that things get dicey. You can always manually edit the PostScript output (which I’ve done) or manipulate it with something like Perl or Python (which I’ve done), but that’s pretty extreme and geeky.
For sure, but sounds just like you from what I know of you so far?
For my limited purposes nowadays - mostly IrTrad tune transcription and an occasional multipart - ABC is great. If I wanted fancier output, I’d import the ABC into e.g. Sibelius or Finale and gussy it up there.
Yep, I’m really just looking at it as this ‘trad standard’ I’d previously been unaware of… but worth learning properly even for that!
Thanks for that (so at least we’ve got an elegant canine tango now!).
Or the flip side, which is that (as a player of tunes) you work with accompanists who basically play the same thing for every tune in the same key (and I’m not sure I’d really expect much better from software)!
Anyway, to get back to my OP for a moment before I forget, I’ve been meaning to point out that my reel An Tilleadh gu Colla should be played as what (for want of a better term) I think of as a ‘bounce reel’… which means slightly swung in the vein of Phil Cunningham’s Cutting a Slide, Jim Sutherland’s The Easy Club Reel or perhaps a pipe reel, and never at breakneck speed.
Thanks for confirming that. But sometimes a drunken pianist is better than none. Altogether now…“My old man said follow the band…”
That is why I allow myself to be a bit pedantic about the mode/key when transcribing to ABC, since I do not want to mislead.
Yes, probably better to let people criticise my ignorance than mock my flaunting of obscure geeky stuff. [crossing with Pete Duggan. I was aiming that geekiness thing at myself.]
Is the problem that the K: field is being used for two things, one essential and unambiguous (what the notes on the staff are) one additional information that may or may not be unambigious (the mode) ? Unambiguous if the composer wants to instruct players that he is thinking of the tune in a particular mode, or a collector of a melody could hear that it was being harmonized in the that mode, or the editor of a collection is passing current convention for the tune. Ambiguous if there are differences of opinion or the composer intended players to come to some agreement amongst themselves.
From the information being coded two fields would make more sense, much in the way as the time signature and rhythm can be coded in separate fields. Is that on option in the specification ? Not having it seems untidy to the programmer in me.
Maybe, in all of the above, someone else has already made the point, but one of the major advantages of staff notation is that it is graphic; you can see the shape of the line and the size of the intervals very clearly at a glance. This is good for melodies, but especially for chords, where the shape of the chord has to be taken in at a glance if you’re sight reading. You can instantly see which inversion it is and what the root note is in conventional notation. (Having said this, I’m sure you can learn to sight read ABC notation if you work at it, just like anything else.) A further advantage of staff notation is that it is easy to transpose at sight, for the same reasons.
These days, anyway, the whole benefit of text-based notation is surely a bit outdated? Sending a jpg or whatever of some staff notation is no longer the big deal it used to be in the old days of slow connections.
While I agree 100% with that (taking us right back to the OP)…
These days, anyway, the whole benefit of text-based notation is surely a bit outdated? Sending a jpg or whatever of some staff notation is no longer the big deal it used to be in the old days of slow connections.
I’m not so sure about that! So, while I’d be much quicker learning something off said .jpg (but prefer a .png if we want it to look nice at tidy file sizes!), the potential value of the ABC’s more as an interchange format to import to something else. (Think .txt file rather than .jpg to process in MS Word or OpenOffice and you’ve got much less work to do…)
And computers can search or manipulate the ABC for various purposes - tune matching, chord generation, lyric searches, transposing/ Even representing it as Staff .
And we can paste ABC on the forum much more easily than posting an image…
And editing is so much easier in ABC - if you have a graphic image, you have to generate a complete new one. Editing is also massively easier than in those blasted drag & drop programs like Sibelius and Finale, which even when you get familiar with them are still bloody awkward. I use ABCEdit and find it excellent. I can clearly see the staff notation I am creating above the ABC I’m writing/editing.
I’ve tried Finale and Sibelius etc. in the past and it takes ages to get familiar with their interfaces and quirks (I never persisted) - far longer than familiarisation with ABC conventions. I think Sib is probably fine if you are inputting by playing a midi instrument, but compiling scores manually with keyboard/mouse etc. is a nightmare!
Have they actually got an ABC import-export function for Sibelius now? They didn’t use to have and from what I heard were snottily resistant to writing/adding/facilitating one…
I think Sib is probably fine if you are inputting by playing a midi instrument, but compiling scores manually with keyboard/mouse etc. is a nightmare!
My experience is quite the opposite, now always working (rapidly!) through computer keyboard and mouse because I’m getting what I want without all the post-input ‘tidying’ baggage that’s prevalent with other methods.
Have they actually got an ABC import-export function for Sibelius now? They didn’t use to have and from what I heard were snottily resistant to writing/adding/facilitating one…
Don’t think so, but I Googled this about the time I started this thread, think it’s maybe possible via the intermediate step of MusicXML and might yet start experimenting with Sibelius plug-ins myself if you give me a year or two (or ten!) to get familiar with both ABC and plug-in specs!
But they’re still letting you express your opinions here?
So you don’t like dots? We know! And the young Mozart allegedly memorised the whole of Allegri’s Miserere from a single hearing. But most of us need more help than that, and that’s where notation comes in (next part of the story is that he sat and wrote it down)!
Anyone know how the PDF rendering thingy at concertina.net’s doing that?
Just ran The Boat that Sailed Backwards through it again and downloaded the PDF to take a look at, but can’t see how the notation’s done (doesn’t look like fonts when just Helvetica & Times are listed, but 11.7 KB file size seems too small for much else).
But we’re agreeing anyway when we’re both answering killthemessenger’s question about text-based notation being outdated with reasons (good interchange format!) why it’s not. And my real point about .png over .jpg is not music-specific, but that .jpg gets routinely overused for graphics which would be better served by other graphic formats.
No, but the Postscript code generated by abcm2ps has, near the start, PostScript graphics definitions for clef signs, tadpoles and the other squiggly bits. Then it proceeds to refer to them much as it would a font. Very compact. The PDF will be that rendered into PDF-speak.
In Acrobat the PDF from concertina.net seems to have similar graphical objects, but not quite the same as it generates itself from the abcm2ps output.