…but here’s the thing: there’s not an aphorism in the bunch. Take this quote on the very subject from Friedrich Nietzsche:
“A good aphorism is too hard for the teeth of time and is not eaten up by all the centuries, even though it serves as food for every age: hence it is the greatest paradox in literature, the imperishable in the midst of change, the nourishment which—like salt—is always prized, but which never loses its savor as salt does.”
While a decent enough explanation of the aphorism’s significance, the above is NOT an aphorism itself; it is essentially running commentary with a cutoff. If ol’ Friedrich had wanted to compose an aphorism on aphorisms, he would have condensed it, thusly for possible example:
“A good aphorism is too hard for the teeth of time, though it serves as food for every age.”
That is an aphorism. Everything in the first example is implicit in the second, all neatly wrapped up and tidy. Incidentally it also frees us from being imposed upon by the poetic convenience but intellectual irrigor of his appearing to lean on precedent in the mishandling of a bit of passing rhetoric - a cultural trope by that time, no doubt, but nevertheless plucked from the Bible, as it happens; so much for being apart from “the herd” - that only asks whatif “the salt” (a metaphor) should lose its flavor (which, in dull fact, real nonmetaphoric salt in its workaday crystalline state cannot do; the Bible never stated otherwise but apparently nobody seems to care, and yet despite knowing better even scientifically, apparently the idea remains unaccountably with us in letters as if it were fact). IMHO Nietzsche might have better left that merely decorative part out. But no matter. A good aphorism is brief, pithy, and above all memorable because not only is it well-composed in its brevity, it often makes us go “a-HA.” But good or not, an aphorism is also not necessarily true; it is, in the end, just short and maybe memorable.
What Talasiga’s doing is workin’ it out. The aphorisms to be gleaned are yet to come, I eagerly anticipate, and then, perhaps, I may be able to follow the topic. So keep at it, Tal, and get me those aphorisms. A theory “stairway to heaven” would be just the ticket for me.
If you take a just intoned perfect fifth (the real perfect fifth) and spell out a cycle of fifths with it you won’t end up at a precisely consonant octave as you do with equal tempered perfect fifth. (not my finding but general info).
And, have you ever thought why slidings are so touching and bring so much elan to trad musics, any music?
Of course everyone, including moderators, is entitled to have fun but I don’t think that I am having fun by mocking others. Not that I am saying that I shouldm’t be mocked. After all I deserve to be mocked don’t I because if I cannot be understood I must be BS?
If someone wants to have fun in the way I am doing it they should have the courage to start a topic which reveals their own evolving thought processes with a hope that it might foster some engagement with others.
Another way to have fun would be to start a topic asking which is the best model expensive C whistle I should buy seeing as I have so much money and the 60 whistles I have do not fulfil my desires. Such topics are popular but alas, for me, it would not be true to form as
I do not have excess money.
I am totally happy with the mid end C that I already have (knowing that as I improve so will its sound) and the Walton C I keep in the car.
There is only one perfect fifth, a frequency interval of 3 to 2.
But the most fundamental just interval is the octave, a frequency interval of 2 to 1, and even ET is recognising this.
It is so fundamental that our brains can be deluded in deciphering in which octave a note is sounding, i.e we may not realise that an octave relationship is there at all, and think the notes are all the same.
This is convenient for the practise of octave folding, where notes in higher octaves are expressed as their lower octave equivalents.
The same practise is used when you “spell out a cycle of fifths”, but a cycle of fifth does not exists in any just intonation system, so perhaps we better forget about this artificial entity here.
The dance of harmonic intervals:
one, two, three, four, five, six…
two-one, three-two, four-three, five-four, six-five…
2:1, 3:2, 4:3, 5:4, 6:5…
which gives us octave, fifth, fourth, major third, minor third…
but going on to seven it’s getting messy:
7:6, 8:7 septimal minor third and septimal major second, not part of the most common just intonation system.
9:8, 10:9 just major tone and just minor tone
and after five more messy intervals: 16:15 just semitone.
You may note that all of these intervals of simple fractions are present in musical tones as harmonic overtones, to various degrees. We may well be hard-wired in ear-brain to perceive some of these. Called the sweetness of intervals.
And then there are those bluesy notes…
Talasiga, it’s convoluted. Suffice it to say that as for asking whether or not you should have all the fun, that was was incidental, based solely on the unfolding of the thread after my rant (which was not a mockery by the way, but a crazy self-indulgence inspired by you - a perhaps subtle but nevertheless very real difference), and the potential promptings to be taken or left as one might. Yes, it all happened to fit the subtext of the mindboggled observer (including my rant if you take a crowbar to it and force it into place). In my world ribbing and mockery are two different things - the latter being strictly malicious, and often obviously so. And while I of all people am well-equipped to read between the lines especially where they don’t actually exist, my charge of “BS” was leveled at myself, so I’ll thank you to not steal my thunder. Moreover your last sentence above is a very bad equation with a sum of null (worse yet, it presumes to understand the workings of my mind, and the presumption fails spectacularly). However, if you find the shoe fits, well, I don’t know what to tell you.
Exactly. So what is Hans counting five of for his self evident just intonation?
…and what is he counting them on? A fiddle, a human voice or a a trumpet?
Or is he counting it on an ET piano where counting 5 notes will not give you a JI anymore than counting 5 whole tones to a seventh will?