Hello,
What are the major differences between Overton Low D and Alba Low D?
The backpressure?
Is it easy to play the second octave with Alba Low D? Need air flow or air pressure? Both?
Thanks a lot for your informations,
Overton: Backpressure, need not so much air, sixth hole easy to reach
Alba: no backpressure, needs much air, sixth hole harder to reach (not as bad as other whistles)
Tone/sound:
Overton: unparalleled; Alba: very beautiful
Overton takes more getting used to and more control. If you don’t play the Overton much, the bottom end is a bit tricky to fill out. The Alba is easier right from the beginning, but harder to control, esp. between the octaves and in the upper reaches.
I didn’t say it was a problem. I find the Alba comfortable to play.
I was refering to the distance between the fifth & sixth hole. I’ve not paid attention to hole diameter that much, it’s not an issue for me. I think the Alba sixth hole is smaller than the Overton sixth hole (it probably has to be, being further from the blade, if I remember my whistle physics).
There are some whistles where I do find the spacing of the 5th & sixth holes a problem: The Susato comes to mind.
I don’t think that between the Alba & Overton hole spacings etc are significant. If you are going to decide between the two, base your decision on the sound (very close call, I prefer the Overton, but like the Alba sound better than all the other low Ds I’ve plaid) and the breath requirements. Overton: little breath, high back pressure. Alba: a lot of breath, no back pressure.
I bought an Overton few weeks ago, you know, see my review http://chiffboard.mati.ca/viewtopic.php?t=15097&highlight=review
I am very very glad.
I hesitate to buy an Alba, but if the difference is to close I don’t want spend money for that, do you understand…
My view on that would be: learn the play the Overton before you get another whistle. But realize that this the kind of good advice I give but don’t follow myself.