Alain Froment Concert D Chanter Fingering

I have a concert pitch chanter which Alain Froment made for me back in 1988. It sounds and plays well, but I have always had to use (what to me is) a non-standard fingering compared with my other chanters for it to play the C natural in tune - basically lifting the two middle fingers of the right hand fully and partially lifting the little finger of that hand also.

Do any other Froment chanter owners have a similar problem, or are your chanters ok with ‘standard’ fingering - if, indeed, there is such a thing?

I would be grateful for any thoughts/comments.

Martin Littleboy.

I don’t think there really is a ‘standard fingering’ for C natural. It’s the note you have to humour. Bend it and tickle it and make it sigh.

Love your discription.Mr.G.

The first reed I had in my chanter would only play C Nat. in tune with (rh player) index finger on left hand, and index and middle fingers on right hand. I was scolded at a Tionol for playing this way and I went to NPU with the question. The answer I received back was similar to Mr. Gumby’s, and was accompanied by three different uilleann pipe tutor fingering charts, with three different fingerings. Do what works!!! In my case, a reed change changed the fingering, and bag pressure helps keep it in tune.

A recent thread raised the same question:

https://forums.chiffandfipple.com/t/froment-d-chanter-c-natural-issue/79361/1

a certain type of reed scrape helps a lot with the c natural.bring the scrape down to the bridle and if you still have a poor note then widen the scrape at the base of the reed until the note comes in,this works on a lot of chanters but some will only play with the g and f sharp holes open and even then the note is weak.allan moller.