I cruised over to The Whistle Shop to check out the Dixons. There are 2 high Ds – one is marked NEW, and has a brass tuning slide. This will be my first tuneable whistle. Is a brass slide worth $12 more than a regular tuning slide? To make things more complicated, there’s also a Dixon set – a high D that comes with a whistle and a piccolo head. Of course, that caught my eye as it might be fun to play with . . . but other than just trying it, is there a reason I might want a piccolo head?
I don’t play the piccolo, so I can’t give you an intelligent answer on that one. As to the brass slide, I think the old tunable one works just fine, sans brass slide. I just play for myself, so I never even adjust it anyway. I could be happy with a non-tunable one, if they were actually available at this time. If I were you, I’d just spend the least amount of money, and you’ll be happy with the result.
Get a tunable; you never know when you might need to play with other instruments that might not be all that in tune. Get the brass slide if you want a very clear pure tone with no breathiness or chiff. Get the all plastic tunable if you want the tone more “trad”-like.
I have the Dixon Hidh D tuneable PVC, it one of my favorites. I’d get that one.
I don’t have the high D/piccolo combo but I do have Dixon’s low D/flute combo. I figured I would get more bang for my buck since both low whistle and flute are popular instruments in Celtic music whereas that is not so much true with a piccolo.
My only other low D experience is tootling about on a friend’s black Howard but the Dixon PVC is nice. It has a smooth, mellow tone. It’s not too breathy and it doesn’t take as much wind as the Howard. The only negative points are that is is a bit quiet and I find I have to clear the fipple of water more. But otherwise it’s a very nice sounding and looking instrument. My only finger adjustments I had to make were on the top hand. The bottom hand was no problem because I play GHB so my bottom hand is use to big spread and big holes. The top hand was a little tougher to adjust to.
As for the flute head… well I’ve never played flute before but I’ve always loved the Irish flute. The tone is nice and clear, a little breathy but not too much so which is good considering I’m just learning to blow flute. It’s not too harsh and the hard D is quite nice. As when it’s in whistle mode I would say it’s maybe a bit quiet but I’ve never really heard a good simple system flute up close and it is definitely louder as a flute than a whistle.
Maybe not a session instrument but definitely a good student flute and rather economical, especially considering you get 2 instruments in 1.
Slainte!
Aaron
[ This Message was edited by: AaronMalcomb on 2002-05-28 23:26 ]